Crit Item Mob List (Compiled)

[Felic]

See below for original post.

With a big thanks to Unique, we have an updated crit item drop list for book 8 changes. Thanks a bunch!

See also http://lorebook.lotro.com/wiki/Crafting_Trophies_Guide

============================== ============================== ============================== ====

Well, since Fizen didn't update his list (props for the original! ) and Book 13 Crit Item MOB List is not compiled, I decided to go ahead and do it myself (got all GMs except MS, so was tired of doing search for crit item mobs). Credit goes to all the people who posted on that thread. I will try to keep this list updated, so please post any corrections and additions.

CREDITS: Analog-Man, Sandgorgan, Dimes, Mael5trom, Jonil, Jayquad, Ebyl, Feycat, Savash, Solona, darkgolem, lonewylfe, GajiroKeiji, MithrilSoul, Jeremy34, Blakaddor, twytan, sir_ego, dh8d1, MeSoHappy, Shardis, Guttataherp, TheSchwazz, theologyman, Cleo256, Narthalion, Rillas, Xaephinx, sylvan1, Linwen, Solona, Lirah, Digital_Utopia, Merant, Buttercup86

List of Crit Items by Profession: http://forums.lotro.com/showthread.php?t=135145
List of new/old items: http://forums.lotro.com/showthread.php?t=134233
List of recipes with crit items: http://www.lotroalliance.com/recipes.php

–––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– ––––––––––––

Blackened Ear –– Bree-Land (North) –– Bears, Wolves, Boars
Blackened Ear –– Barrow Downs –– Barghests
Blackened Ear –– Lone Lands (Weather HIlls) –– Wolves

Blackened Tail –– Lone Lands (West near Forsaken Inn) –– Wargs
Blackened Tail –– Barrow Downs –– Barghests

Black Heartwood –– Lone Lands (Haragmar, Agamaur & GA) –– Gloomleaf, Darkheart,

Broken Heartwood –– Old Forest –– Warped Oaks, Grim Barren-Oaks
Broken Heartwood –– Southern Barrow Downs –– Wretched Barrow Maple

Broken Root –– Southern Barrow Downs –– Wretched/Dreadful Barrow Maple

Clouded Eye –– Bree-Land (Midgewater Marshes) –– Neeker-Breekers, Spiders
Clouded Eye –– Ered Luin –– Spiders

Colourful Eye –– Trollshaws –– Worms
Colourful Eye –– Haudh Iarchith (Bree Rep Dungeon) –– Spiders
Colourful Eye –– Misty Mountains –– Snow Lurkers, Worms

Dark Eye –– Old Forest –– Spiders

Delicate Wing –– Bree-Land (Midgewater Marshes) –– Greater Sickle-Flies

Dismissal Treasure –– Barrow Downs –– Wights

Dusky Claw –– Lone Lands (Nain Enidh) –– Crows, Lynx
Dusky Claw –– North Downs (Greenway) –– Cruel-Beaks
Dusky Claw –– North Downs (Fields of Fornost) –– Bears

Dusty Egg Sac (no apparent use) –– Barrow Downs –– Creeping Barrow-Crawler

Dusty Tail –– Angmar –– Wargs
Dusty Tail –– Misty Mountains –– Mammoths
Dusty Tail –– Trollshaws (Giant Valley) –– Drakes
Dusty Tail –– Trollshaws (Tal Bruinen) –– Deer

Flawed Claw –– North Downs (Fields of Fornost) –– Bear, Fell-Grip Barghests
Flawed Claw –– North Downs (Kingsfell) –– Lynx, North-Hawks
Flawed Claw –– North Downs (Kingsfell) –– Roving Wargs

Flawed Ear –– Evendim (Bullroarer's Sward) –– Wolves
Flawed Ear –– Lone Lands –– Warg Scrub-Stalker
Flawed Ear –– North Downs (Meluinen) –– Roving Wargs

Flawed Heartwood –– Southern Barrow Downs –– Wretched/Dreadful Barrow Maple

Great Claw –– Forochel –– Bears, Sabretooths, Wolverines, Peikko
Great Claw –– Sarnur –– Hendrovail

Grey Claw –– Trollshaws (Bruinen Gorges) –– Swift Crag-Hawk
Grey Claw –– Evendim (Tyrn Fornech) –– Bears (>= 35)
Grey Claw –– Evendim (Tyl Ruinen) –– Crawling Rock-Shells (Turtles)

Grey Ear –– Trollshaws (Southern) –– Wolves
Grey Ear –– Evendim (Tyrn Fornech) –– Twilight-Howlers (Wargs)

Grey Eye –– Evendim (Barandalf) –– Creeping Sand-Lurker, Norbolgs, Salamanders
Grey Eye –– Ram Duath –– Worms
Grey Eye –– North Downs (Nan Amlug East) –– Spiders

Grey Tail –– Evendim (Tyrn Fornech) –– Hill-Hinds (Deer), Twilight-Howlers (Wargs)
Grey Tail –– Evendim (Parth Aduial) –– Barghests (>= 35)
Grey Tail –– Trollshaws –– Glen-Bucks/Glen-Hinds (Deer >= 35)

Large Treasure –– Trollshaws (Nan Tornaeth) –– Wights
Large Treasure –– Haudh Iarchith (Bree Rep Dungeon) –– Wights

Large Skull –– Lone Lands (Haragmar, Agamaur & GA) –– Wights

Ragged Tail –– North Downs (Fields of Fornost) –– Fell-Grip/Dread Barghests
Ragged Tail –– North Downs (Kingsfell, Meluinen) –– Roving Wargs, Hoar-Mantles

Red Eye –– Evendim (Oatbarton) –– Swarming Locusts, Spiders

Scarred Tail –– Ram Duath –– Drakes
Scarred Tail –– Evendim (North) –– Barghests (< 35)

Small Treasure –– Ered Luin (Haudh Lin) –– Wights (low drop rate, mixed with Dismissal)

Stained Treasure –– Lone Lands (Agamaur & GA) –– Wights

Tarnished Treasure –– Lone Lands (Harloeg) –– Wights

Torn Claw –– Various –– Beasts (lvl 8-10)

Tough Leg –– Ram Duath –– Cave Claw
Tough Leg –– Trollshaws (Wovenvales) –– Spiders
Tough Leg –– Trollshaws (Tal Bruinen) –– Demon Frogs
Tough Leg –– Haudh Iarchith (Bree Rep Dungeon) –– Spiders

Yellowed Claw South Trollshaws Corrupt Darkclaw

[Felic]

Crafting recipe items (non-crit) drop list:

WOODWORKER
Champion horns:
Delicate Horn –– Bree-Land (Midgewater Marshes) –– Neeker-Breekers
Streaked Horn –– North Downs (Kingsfell) –– Hoar-Mantles
Slender Horn –– Misty Mountains –– Aurochs, Snow Beasts

TAILOR
Hoary Aurcochs Robe:
Hoary Aurochs Hide –– Forochel –– Hoary Aurcochs

Torahammas Mammoth spawns right in front of the Gauradain camp just on the right of Ziggy

SCHOLAR
T1:
Gold Dye –– Yarrow Root (ground spawn)
Pea-Green Paint –– Lilly-of-the-Valley Leaf (farming by-product)*
Sienna Dye –– Sienna (Tin deposit by-product)
T2:
Grey Dye –– Iris Root (farming by-product)*
Olive Dye –– Copper Salts (Copper deposit by-product)
Umber Dye –– Umber (Barrow-Iron deposit by-product)
T3:
Navy Dye –– Woad (ground spawn)
Turquoise Dye/Sky-Blue Paint –– Bluebottle Petal (farming by-product)*
Violet Dye –– Juicy Blackberries (farming by-product)
T4:
Burgundy Dye –– Amaranth Petal (farming by-product)*
Dark Green Dye –– Onion Skins (farming by-product: Green onions)
Indigo Dye –– Indigo Plant (ground spawn)
Pale Yellow Paint –– Saffron Thread (farming by-product)*
Pink Paint –– Juicy Strawberry (farming by-product)*
T5:
Lavender Paint –– Juicy Elderberry (farming by-product)*
Orange Dye/Pumpkin-Orange Paint –– Bloodwort Root (farming by-product)*
Red Dye –– Juicy Strawberries (farming by-product)*
Rust/Black Dye –– Ancient Iron Oxides (AI deposit by-product)

White Dye –– Chunk of Lime (Khazad-iron deposits)**

* changes/additions as of Vol 1 Bk 14.
** changes/additions as of Vol 2 Bk 8.

[Cleo256]

Good list! Glen-hinds in the South trollshaws also drop Grey Tails. I know because I spent a lot of time killing deer in that area to get a stack, and they dropped off both Glen-hinds and Glen-bucks. They had to be level 35, though. Anything under level 35 seemed to drop Scarred Tails instead.

[Strongbow]

Grey Claws also drop off of the bears in Evendim, east of Ost Forod

[Narthalion]

Frogs near Tal Bruinen also drop tough legs. And Misty Mountain worms also drop colorful eyes.

[Hakon_Stormbrow]

I would recomend you either post this on lorebook or put it on your own server. I lost a lot of good work when they purged the forums in March, I would hate to see that happen to you next time.

[Digero]

Originally Posted by Hakon_Stormbrow

I would recomend you either post this on lorebook or put it on your own server. I lost a lot of good work when they purged the forums in March, I would hate to see that happen to you next time.

If you post it on the lorebook, that will allow others to more easily help fill in the ?s as well

[Ebyl]

Dusty Tails drop from Great Glen-hinds and (I assume) from Great Glen-bucks in the Trollshaws (Tal Bruinen, etc.). The drop does seem to be pretty rare.

[Rillas]

Thanks for the list! Great!

Dark Eyes drop from Forest Tree-spinners and Forest Web-weavers in the Old Forest.

[Felic]

Originally Posted by Hakon_Stormbrow

I would recomend you either post this on lorebook or put it on your own server. I lost a lot of good work when they purged the forums in March, I would hate to see that happen to you next time.

Thanks for the advice, I'll look into it. I am keeping the list in a text file on my comp though for now, just in case.

[Ebyl]

Grey Claws drop from the Crawling Rock-Shells on Tyl Ruinen (the salamander island) in Evendim.

[Ebyl]

Got a great claw off a Giant Snow-bear in the Giant Halls (Misty Mountains).

[koifishkid]

Small Treasures drop off the wights in Haudh Lin in Ered Luin near the burial mounds.

[Felic]

Update: in the 2nd post, I separated out the non-crit recipe items that are either drops or plants or farming/mining by-products. I know there's a Torahammas mammoth somewhere, still haven't found it on Roheryn so will wait to get more info on that. If I missed any, please post the info, thanks.

[dafyd]

Thanks for putting this together. Fizen stopped playing awhile ago (he posted about it) and I thought someone else was taking over managing his pages but it seems that didn't happen.