New Crit Item/Profession Reference

[Ascus]

Updated for Moria

Profession's use of Crit Items by Tier:
Jeweller
1 Small Treasure, Dismal Treasure
2 Tarnished Treasure, Dusky Claw
3 Large Treasure, Stained Treasure
4 Dusty Tail, Great Claw
5 Great Claw
6 Glossy Eye, Elegant Eye

Metalsmith
1 Torn Claw, Blackened Tail
2 Broken Heartwood, Dusky Claw
3 Ragged Tail, Large Skull
4 Grey Ear, Colourful Eye
5 Great Claw
6 Barbed Leg, Jagged Leg

Scholar
1 Clouded Eye
2 Dark Eye
3 Red Eye (dyes: Colourful Eye)
4 Grey Eye
5 Colourful Eye
6 Glossy Eye, Elegant Eye

Tailor
1 Torn Claw
2 Blackened Tail, Broken Root
3 Ragged Tail, Scared Tail
4 Grey Tail, Dusty Tail
5 Great Claw
6 Barbed Leg, Jagged Leg

Weaponsmith
1 Torn Claw
2 Blackened Claw, Dusky Claw
3 Flawed Claw, Yellowed Claw
4 Grey Claw, White Claw
5 Deadly Claw, Great Claw
6 Charming Tail, Smooth Tail

Woodworking
1 Delicate Wing, Torn Claw
2 Broken Heartwood, Flawed Heartwood
3 Scarred Heartwood, Black Heartwood
4 Grey Claw, Tough Leg
5 Great Claw
6 Charming Tail, Smooth Tail

Where Crit Items are used:
Item -- Profession (Tier)
Barbed Leg --- Metalsmith, Tailor (6)
Black Heartwood --- Woodworking (3)
Blackened Claw --- Weaponsmith (2)
Blackened Tail --- Metalsmith (1), Tailor (2)
Broken Heartwood --- Metalsmith, Woodworker (2)
Broken Root --- Tailor (2)
Charming Tail --- Weaponsmith, Woodworker (6)
Clouded Eye --- Scholar (1)
Colourful Eye --- Metalsmith (4), Scholar (3&5)
Dark Eye --- Scholar (2)
Deadly Claw --- Weaponsmith (5)
Delicate Wing --- Woodworking (1)
Dismal Treasure --- Jeweller (1)
Dusky Claw --- Jeweller, Metalsmith, Weaponsmith (2)
Dusty Tail --- Jeweller, Tailor (4)
Elegant Eye --- Jeweller, Scholar (6)
Flawed Claw --- Weaponsmith (3)
Flawed Heartwood --- Woodworking (2)
Glossy Eye -- Jeweller, Scholar (6)
Great Claw --- Jeweller (4&5), Metalsmith, Tailor, Weaponsmith, Woodworking (5)
Grey Claw --- Weaponsmith, Woodworking (4)
Grey Ear --- Metalsmith (4)
Grey Eye --- Scholar(4)
Grey Tail --- Tailor (4)
Jagged Leg --- Metalsmith, Tailor (6)
Large Skull --- Metalsmith (3)
Large Treasure --- Jeweller (3)
Ragged Tail --- Metalsmith, Tailor (3)
Red Eye --- Scholar (3)
Scarred Tail --- Tailor (3)
Scarred Heartwood --- Woodworking (3)
Small Treasure --- Jeweller (1)
Smooth Tail --- Weaponsmith, Woodworker (6)
Stained Treasure --- Jeweller (3)
Tarnished Treasure --- Jeweller (2)
Torn Claw --- Metalsmith, Tailor, Weaponsmith, Woodworking (1)
Tough Leg --- Woodworking (4)
White Claw --- Weaponsmith (4)
Yellowed Claw --- Weaponsmith (3)

Arranged By Tier
Tier 1: Apprentice
Blackened Tail --- Metalsmith
Clouded Eye --- Scholar
Delicate Wing --- Woodworking
Dismal Treasure --- Jeweller
Small Treasure --- Jeweller
Torn Claw --- Metalsmith, Tailor, Weaponsmith, Woodworking

Tier 2: Journeyman
Blackened Claw --- Weaponsmith
Blackened Tail --- Tailor
Broken Heartwood --- Metalsmith, Woodworker
Broken Root --- Tailor
Dark Eye --- Scholar
Dusky Claw --- Jeweller, Metalsmith, Weaponsmith
Flawed Heartwood --- Woodworking
Tarnished Treasure --- Jeweller

Tier 3: Expert
Black Heartwood --- Woodworking
Colourful Eye --- Scholar
Flawed Claw --- Weaponsmith
Large Skull --- Metalsmith
Large Treasure --- Jeweller
Ragged Tail --- Metalsmith, Tailor
Red Eye --- Scholar
Scarred Tail --- Tailor
Scarred Heartwood --- Woodworking
Stained Treasure --- Jeweller
Yellowed Claw --- Weaponsmith

Tier 4: Artisan
Colourful Eye --- Metalsmith
Dusty Tail --- Jeweller, Tailor
Great Claw --- Jeweller
Grey Claw --- Weaponsmith, Woodworking
Grey Ear --- Metalsmith
Grey Eye --- Scholar
Grey Tail --- Tailor
Tough Leg --- Woodworking
White Claw --- Weaponsmith

Tier 5: Master
Colourful Eye --- Scholar
Deadly Claw --- Weaponsmith
Great Claw --- Jeweller, Metalsmith, Tailor, Weaponsmith, [item]Woodworking

Tier 6: Supreme
Barbed Leg --- Metalsmith, Tailor
Charming Tail --- Weaponsmith, Woodworker
Elegant Eye --- Jeweller, Scholar
Glossy Eye -- Jeweller, Scholar
Jagged Leg --- Metalsmith, Tailor
Smooth Tail --- Weaponsmith, Woodworker

[TsarithArcher]

Bless you, bless you, bless you!

You are now my newest hero!

[Savash]

Wonderful!
Now how about a list of what drops what?

[ArtemisNoir]

Oh thank you so much!!!! I was wondering if somebody had done this yet, and was about to begin compiling a list myself.

[Manderero]

You can also see the recipes that require these items at http://www.lotroalliance.com/recipes.php.

Clicking the vocation brings up the tiers, clicking the tier brings up the recipe types. This is where the crit items are shown. All the recipes under the same type require the same crit item.

One more click brings up the recipes. If you click a recipe you can see the ingredients needed to craft.

Mousing over the icons show you the tooltip - just like in-game!

[johris]

Tagged. Thanks for putting this together

[Digero]

Awesome, thank you!

Also, thanks Manderero for posting that link, it looks like a great resource.

[Nythalia]

Originally Posted by Ascus

Profession's use of Crit Items by Tier:

You, sir, are a gentleman and a scholar.

... or a jeweller... or tailor... or something.

...but definitely a gentleman! Unless, of course, you are a gentlewoman. Bah...

Thank you very much for the list! It shall prove most helpful.

- Nythalia

[Madmac51]

The fun part is going to be figuring out what other critters are going to drop the item. ie. the 'new' Tough Leg was 'Extremely Sharp Cave Claw Talon. I would assume those cave claw guys will drop the new leg. But unlike some new items that have a couple of old barter items, the barter guy in Bree only has the one entry for the tough leg.

[Caricia]

Yay! Thanks for this!
Now, has anyone found out what are Dusty Egg Sacs for? They are turned in for Blackened Spiders Eyes and which were used in Journeyman Scholar's potions. I can't find any use for those now.

[Ayrolen]

Nice post, man. Thank you! /golf_clap

[AilsaN]

I can't tell you how much I appreciate you putting this list together!! You are my hero!!

[truthiness]

Great Post! Thank you so much for the info!

To get the new crit items, we have to turn in the old crit items to a barter NPC. After the latest update, hunting still has us picking up the old crit items from creature kills, so it looks like it will be necessary to keep stack space for both all the old crit items and the new ones.

The only barter NPC for the exchange of old for new crit items that I am aware of is in the Crafting Hall at Bree, which means that traveling all the way back to Bree will be required every time you want to get a new crit item. Hopefully there are other places you can do this, but I haven't found one yet. Does anyone know of any other place with this type of barter NPC?

[Manderero]

Originally Posted by truthiness

The only barter NPC for the exchange of old for new crit items that I am aware of is in the Crafting Hall at Bree, which means that traveling all the way back to Bree will be required every time you want to get a new crit item. Hopefully there are other places you can do this, but I haven't found one yet. Does anyone know of any other place with this type of barter NPC?

The old item tooltip description only has Taddyn in Bree listed as a place to turn in the items. That is the only place we can go at this time...

[koifishkid]

It looks like woodworkers still have to hit up Garth Agarwen for crit items. I thought the crit items were going to be the same for every craft (for example, all tier 3 recipes would use a Scarred Ear, or something). This doesn't save bag space or time for woodworkers - it's the same items with different names.