Thread: dargnakh tier 1 deed confusion

group of friends and I finished tier 1 Dargnakh last night - but it turns out, NONE of us had completed it before, and NONE of us got the deed completion for Dargnakh tier 1

so, I've done some rummaging through the forum search engines, and there seems to be some confusion

some people claim that you only get the deed completion from personally killing dargnakh, while others claim that they've successfully gotten the deed by allowing dargnakh to stone himself by breaking down the pillars - at least one person mentioned that there's a known bug with the deed, but I can't seem to find that thread

does anyone have confirmation for any of these three possibilities? and is it possible that personally killing dargnakh is a workaround FOR the bug?

just for the sake of complete disclosure, we both bugged the deed AND contacted a GM - GM informed us that they were unable to fix the problem

There should be 2 deeds:

Challenge: Dargnakh Unleashed For killing the troll with sunlight.

Commanders of Isengard -- Tier I For killing the troll personally.

To complete the Tier 1 deed you have to actually kill him, NOT use the pillars/sunlight. Anyone claiming to have completed Tier 1 using the pillars/sunlight is mistaken.

thank you both - I'll have to give that a shot next time 'round