+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast
Results 1 to 40 of 105
  1. #1
    Senior Member Online status: spockerized is offline Reputation: spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Anchorage, Alaska
    Posts
    640

    The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Let's look at this from the most logical point. A squishy class that really only makes the job of a healer harder when faced with burst damage. The actual damage done by a Lm is laughable and the pets hit for what 64? What is always the first class to die... The LM. Look at these points.

    1. The Bosses that anyone does in ToO are zerg bosses no need for CC.
    2. Because how short the bosses are the debuffs actually help mitigate what damage.
    3. Since most of the damage that happens in these fights is melee seems logical to stack burgs.. More debuffs+outgoing damage.
    4. At this point everyone should have enough ICPR or class skills to sustain dps plus the fights are short again. You bring a lm just for Power looks like a fail raid.
    5. If you bring a class for 1 skill say SI looks like the raid is fail?

    Sorry to burst your bubble but someone had to say it.

  2. #2
    Senior Member Online status: Yargesh is offline Reputation: Yargesh the Wary Yargesh the Wary Yargesh the Wary
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Posts
    164

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    So what you are saying is you don't like LM's?
    So what?

  3. #3
    Senior Member Online status: spockerized is offline Reputation: spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Anchorage, Alaska
    Posts
    640

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    I just don't see a use for them..
    And apparently neither do you :?

  4. #4
    Member Online status: Vilifica is offline Reputation: Vilifica the Neutral
    Join Date
    Dec 2010
    Location
    Nevada
    Posts
    34

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    You must have some fail LMs on your server. Are you are one?

  5. #5
    Senior Member Online status: spockerized is offline Reputation: spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Anchorage, Alaska
    Posts
    640

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    What makes them good? 0 for 2 so far :?

  6. #6
    Senior Member Online status: Ravenstride is offline Reputation: Ravenstride the Wary Ravenstride the Wary Ravenstride the Wary Ravenstride the Wary
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    275

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    I kinda like Frost Lore. Especially in Orthanc.

    Fire Lore is great for Trash pulls. I know I like the 8 target de-buffs when I'm tanking on Warden.

    Keeping 2 trolls stunned by 1 LM leaves burgs to dps more or stun only on resist.

    -Crit chance is, once again, very much appreciated by Tanks.

    BPE AoE debuffs are appreciated by Champs for sure.

    I'm sure i could find 2-3 more reasons if i tried but for me that is already enough to bring at least 1 LM when raiding.

  7. #7
    Grand Member Online status: Tarenius is offline Reputation: Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Location
    York, UK
    Posts
    1,127

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    LMs have an (almost) equivalent of RW + CD in AC + SaE (with draigoch set, which I have macroed). If you have RKs (circle) or hunters using fire oil (raven/tar), I'm pretty sure we surpass a burg in terms of +inc damage debuffs. Then you have all the defensive debuffs, raven tac mit buff, SI, off heals (I intend to get 3 pcs of the moors set so I can have BoH hot again), power share, better CC, ranged corruption removal... Of course you loose the ST damage of the burg, but for anything hard it is clearly worth it. I don't understand the survivability problems... For a raiding LM will is not particularly important, so you are free to focus more on finesse/morale/tactical mit. Burgs that want to do good DPS can't do the same.

    So what if you can do fights you have on farm without a LM? You can also do them without burgs. LMs don't stack at all, so more than 1 is a waste of a spot, but that has always been the case.

    Maybe you are just trolling (nice avatar), but there are many people who seem to think this is true. Only the other day in global there were people arguing that you shouldn't bother with LMs for T2 Orthanc and just take another burg instead.
    Last edited by Tarenius; Apr 18 2012 at 09:33 AM.

    .: R8 LM/Captain/Hunter/Burg/RK ~ R6 Guardian/Minstrel/Warden :.
    .: R10 WL ~ R9 Reaver/Wuarg ~ R8 Spider/BA ~ R6 Defiler :.

  8. #8
    Grand Member Online status: silverblade5445 is offline Reputation: silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Location
    India
    Posts
    1,594

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Haha...gotta love people who cant play/dont know how the class works and directly reach the conclusion that the class is useless instead of coming here in humility and asking for help in understanding

    So lets break it down -

    Quote Originally Posted by spockerized View Post
    Let's look at this from the most logical point. A squishy class that really only makes the job of a healer harder when faced with burst damage. The actual damage done by a Lm is laughable and the pets hit for what 64? What is always the first class to die... The LM. Look at these points.
    Actual damage done by a loremaster is far better than you know of.....I can outdo most Hunters, Champs and Rks in burst damage.....let alone the other classes.... A LM is not squishy if played even above average.....even in the face of burst damage....A pet is not supposed to blow something up for you....do understand pets and their skills and uses before coming to criticize them......unless played by a total noob, the LM should NEVER be the first class to die. Period. If you are having these things happening, youre doing something wrong.... Big time....

    1. The Bosses that anyone does in ToO are zerg bosses no need for CC.
    Have you been inside ToO?....you couldve used much better examples to show that CC is not needed....but ToO is the most cc-demanding of all instances....Do try it....you'll be surprised.....

    2. Because how short the bosses are the debuffs actually help mitigate what damage.
    I dont know what you mean by short, but do try to fight Saruman or ToO t2 (or even t1 for that matter) and many other instance bosses without debuffs.....you'll be surprised at how fail and inefficient a dps race really is....

    3. Since most of the damage that happens in these fights is melee seems logical to stack burgs.. More debuffs+outgoing damage.
    I dont know what you mean here either.....we have melee/ranged/tactical debuffs far stronger than burgs....not to mention, we have other debuffs...crit chance, avoidances, attack duration, etc.....And all our skills are ranged, so we dont need to risk going into the boss's AoE range to pull em off unlike Burgs....

    4. At this point everyone should have enough ICPR or class skills to sustain dps plus the fights are short again. You bring a lm just for Power looks like a fail raid.
    It is one of the LM's many many jobs (read LM basics for more info on said jobs)....and many fights are longer than many dps races....if you think every class has an equal amount of ICPR at lvl 75 and it should be awesome, youre sadly mistaken....power batteries are needed and running out of power is not fail....its natural....

    5. If you bring a class for 1 skill say SI looks like the raid is fail?
    Again, one of the many roles....I'll point out to reading LM basics for more info on said roles

    Sorry to burst your bubble but someone had to say it.
    Sorry to burst -your- bubble, but you need to play a class and learn it, to know anything about it....even for successful trolling if its an attempt at that.....this is too bad even for a troll post....sorry mate....you need a good informed base to even bash something successfully....not everyone can do that....

    I have never been refused to a fellowship and am invited to planned raids beforehand so that I may make time....a well played LM is a huge asset to any group/raid.....those who know what theyre doing know the importance of an LM in a group......and those who do not understand that only deprive themselves of a big advantage.....

    Ivalden - 75 Captain (R2) - Imladris
    Drankorg - Warg (R5) - Landroval

  9. #9
    Member Online status: Mystion_EU is offline Reputation: Mystion_EU the Wary Mystion_EU the Wary
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    75

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Just to add to the valid points made above:

    -Most, if not all damage you take in ToO is tacical. Tactical mitigation has a cap, and frost-lore is the single most helpful debuff in there. Reduces outgoing tactical boss damage by 25% What else would you want?

    -Also, I still find myself sharing power. Particularly in Saruman Phase 5, because you are prone to spikes that cost a lot of power to outheal, and deaths which need to be powered up again. You barely have to wait between phases.

    Yes, for CC you could replace a LM with another burg AND have a hunter root AND a minstrel fear.. But then you`re wasting 3 classes` valuable time.

    There`s plenty of other reasons you can take a LM to ToO but since you`re obviously leading raids like a pro there I won`t have to tell you any tactics.

  10. #10
    Grand Member Online status: Tarenius is offline Reputation: Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Location
    York, UK
    Posts
    1,127

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    -Most, if not all damage you take in ToO is tacical. Tactical mitigation has a cap, and frost-lore is the single most helpful debuff in there. Reduces outgoing tactical boss damage by 25% What else would you want?

    Actually, it isn't. Damage type (tactical/physical) =/= Damage source (melee/ranged/tactical). In the Saruman fight basically all of the dangerous damage is tactical, but lightning/f&f are pretty equally spread (melee/tactical lighting, all 3 f&f) and acid/shadow are almost entirely melee.

    .: R8 LM/Captain/Hunter/Burg/RK ~ R6 Guardian/Minstrel/Warden :.
    .: R10 WL ~ R9 Reaver/Wuarg ~ R8 Spider/BA ~ R6 Defiler :.

  11. #11
    Senior Member Online status: Moejo is offline Reputation: Moejo the Wary Moejo the Wary Moejo the Wary Moejo the Wary
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Location
    The Shire
    Posts
    691

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    There is but one master of the ring and he does not share power. I guess Sauron wasn't a LM. On topic, while the LM might not be needed for power as much any more, I still couldn't say they were useless. The debuffs speed up any encounter, or make it easier on healers, as does cc. They can even off-tank an add or 2 with a bear. What more could you ask for?

  12. #12
    Member Online status: Mystion_EU is offline Reputation: Mystion_EU the Wary Mystion_EU the Wary
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    75

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by Tarenius View Post
    Actually, it isn't. Damage type (tactical/physical) =/= Damage source (melee/ranged/tactical). In the Saruman fight basically all of the dangerous damage is tactical, but lightning/f&f are pretty equally spread (melee/tactical lighting, all 3 f&f) and acid/shadow are almost entirely melee.[/COLOR]
    Yes, ofcourse! *blush* Serves me right for typing without thinking!
    I was going on about the big boss upstairs, but shouldn`t have put `most/all` without mentioning.
    Still the point kind of stands, tactical damage is dangerous, particularly if it spikes/crits. And the debuff files off a chunk.

  13. #13
    Poster of Note Online status: anteku is offline Reputation: anteku the Neophyte anteku the Neophyte anteku the Neophyte anteku the Neophyte anteku the Neophyte anteku the Neophyte
    Join Date
    Dec 2010
    Posts
    561

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by spockerized View Post
    A squishy class that really only makes the job of a healer harder when faced with burst damage.... What is always the first class to die... The LM. .
    I think the others have made good points.

    Regarding the quoted text, this isn't true from my experience. In our group, the LM is usually among the last 3 people to die. Perhaps your LMs would benefit from new positioning, stacking morale, and retraiting some virtues. In fact, there are a few parts where we actually do a little LM-tanking (e.g. the LM catches the boulders in FnF T2). I don't want to oversell this last point, but do want to note out that we can be fairly sturdy.

    Anyway, an argument can be made that most classes can have their jobs done better by other classes, and this argument keeps changing with updates (e.g. wardens vs. guards; champs vs. hunters; minis vs RKs). One can min-max their groups as much as possible, but for me it's more about having good people rather than perfect classes.

    Quote Originally Posted by Tarenius View Post
    So what if you can do fights you have on farm without a LM? You can also do them without burgs.
    Tarneius makes a good point about things on farm. Once you get the mechanics down, nearly all classes are replaceable. But I challenge you to try to *learn* a new raid without a LM.

  14. #14
    Century Member Online status: Despotis is offline Reputation: Despotis the Neutral
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    119

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    What a LM can offer to a group (in the current raid situation) is majorly underpowered compared to what it was say at level 60 or 65. The OP's concerns have been my concerns for a while despite raiding with my LM whole of orthanc in a solid basis. No, the LM being the first to die is not the problem (though Fire Frost t2 might disagree) but the debuffs are more trivial than ever and the dps additions to the group are negligible compared to burgs.

  15. #15
    Junior Member Online status: Thurinandir is offline Reputation: Thurinandir the Neutral
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    22

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by spockerized View Post
    Let's look at this from the most logical point. A squishy class that really only makes the job of a healer harder when faced with burst damage.
    If us reducing a mobs damage output, hit chance, supporting with additional heals (Beacon of Hope, Improved Flanking, Limfran etc.), removing wounds and reducing damage on static targets through stuns makes a healer's job harder, then I'm not sure healing is what it used to be any more.

    The actual damage done by a Lm is laughable and the pets hit for what 64?
    The damage an LM can churn out is surprisingly high. Burning Embers, a Lore Master's cookie cutter attack at range, on my LM (which is by no means fully kitted out) hits for 500-850 without me being set up for DPS. And as far as I've seen some of the LMs here, that's still quite low. That's on a skill with a 3 second cool down and 30 metre range. And that's in the bottom half of our damaging skills! And not to forget, we have the highest auto-attack damage in the game.

    As for our pets, if their sole purpose was to deal damage, we wouldn't have so many different ones. Eagles buff ICPR, offer us a free revive and can even fear mobs. The Bog Lurker is capable of starting fellowship manoeuvres and flanks frequently enough for us to churn out some noticeable healing - especially when Air Lore is on a tank. The raven offers tactical mitigation and reduces mobs fire resistance, the Lynx can dish out significantly more DPS than 64 per hit (often scoring crits of 1500+), a bear which can pull a mob completely off anyone else for 10 seconds and increase incoming damage for everyone and a Sabre Tooth cat which can hit everything all the time, start fellowship manoeuvres and debuff frost mitigations for a full group.

    And then there's the Limfran, which may not do damage, but it can help out with healing. So yes, pets may not dish out immense amounts of damage, but it's a short sighted view to assume that is the sole purpose of a pet. Captains don't use heralds exclusively for the damage they deal.

    What is always the first class to die... The LM.
    I find it's always RKs and hunters that go down first. And if anything, I'm amongst the last to die. I'm not high enough up the agro pile and any LM stupid enough to get in Melee range of an AoE mob doing a lot of damage is hardly room for a comparison. That's a player fault, not a class fault.

    1. The Bosses that anyone does in ToO are zerg bosses no need for CC.
    Not every fight in every raid is a boss fight. And not everything a LM does is CC based. Take a look at Frost/Fire wing. Those diseases come thick and fast and one slight slip up means everyone is stunned. A LM can prevent both the disease and the stun. Couple that with CCing the mobs doing it in the first place, debuffing their inductions and damage output, I'd say that's a million miles from 'not useful'.

    2. Because how short the bosses are the debuffs actually help mitigate what damage.
    Not every fight is a boss fight. See above.

    Also, LMs do a little more than just debuff.

    3. Since most of the damage that happens in these fights is melee seems logical to stack burgs.. More debuffs+outgoing damage.
    LMs have more debuffs than burgs and the two classes have totally different types of debuffs to boot. And let's not forget, LMs debuffs are AoE without needing traits. And although a burg can trait theirs to hit more than one target, and LM can go much higher. And besides, stack burgs if you wish, but you only need one LM to put in every debuff they have on multiple targets.

    The damage output between the two classes isn't that different. A burg is quicker, an LM does more burst damage. The DPS would be marginal and certainly not a big enough gap to make a difference with regards to everything else each class can do.

    4. At this point everyone should have enough ICPR or class skills to sustain dps plus the fights are short again. You bring a lm just for Power looks like a fail raid.
    In a way, true. If you bring an LM exclusively for power, then that would stink of a raid oblivious to what an LM can do. My LM has close to 2k ICPR unbuffed and I doubt anyone complains when I'm sharing out the blue stuff. And since I can pretty much fully function on an empty blue bar, the group/raid tends to be a little more at ease knowing my blue bar is their blue bar.

    5. If you bring a class for 1 skill say SI looks like the raid is fail?
    Same could be said for any class. This isn't a class limitation, it's a limitation of whoever is pulling the raid/group together.

    Sorry to burst your bubble but someone had to say it.
    So if this is the case, does that mean people who simply enjoy playing the class should stop playing it? LM has rapidly overtaken my champ as the class I play the most and that's simply because of how much they can do. An LM isn't an obvious game changer like a tank or healer. Or even a DPS class. But one thing it will do is make a fight much easier in all the little places. A good LM won't look to get noticed for all the work they do, they'll just do it.

    Simple reality is, a LM is just as useful as it's always been. But it's also just as much a mystery to non-LMs as it's always been too.

  16. #16
    Member Online status: Brinuw is offline Reputation: Brinuw the Neutral
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Posts
    58

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Im gonna have to disagree with the OP. As pretty much the only raid-level Lore-Master in my kinship (a few rarely played alts surface from time to time) I can say that the Lore-Master is a welcome addition to a raid. My alt is a Burglar and having run 3/5 ToO fights on both toons, most of the time while on my Burglar I wish I was on my Lm.

    For instance; a resisted mez on a burglar, that means you have to either hit Confound (15s then mez), then Trick+Startling Twist (8s stun), and even then there is time for the mob to move before the confound mez kicks in (pending if a burg has the countdown legacy. I dont know the burglar community well enough to know if that legacy is often used).

    Same situation on a LM, Herb-lore (30s root for 3-8 mobs)/Cracked Earth (30s root after 5s if traited yellow, it's ToO good chance your traited yellow)/Stun skills (we've got a bunch)

    The last lightning wing run that I was apart of on my LM, both of the trolls was broken out of their mez, so I told the tanks to not build any threat on the trolls, Herb-lore, mez one, 15s later mez the other, and as one mez would end I would stun them, and remez. Since the trolls were targeting me, when the mez would end the troll would have to run a ways towards me. I juggled the trolls long enough for the rest of the group to kill everything else and ultimately saved the run from a wipe. Now Im not all that trained with my Burglar, but I don't figure I could do such a feat with that class. (I am going to try now that i've mentioned it though)

    Maybe an LM has finished all of ToO (close but not there yet myself), the CC set of armor gives +5s to Blinding flash. that makes such a juggling act even easier because you dont have to stun in between any more. Keep in mind, this is only 1 side of a very diverse skill set class, if u calculate in all the debuffs, off-heals, and damage then I firmly believe that LM's are more than useful!

  17. #17
    Member Online status: DaviLOTR is offline Reputation: DaviLOTR the Wary DaviLOTR the Wary DaviLOTR the Wary
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Posts
    69

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    OP is definitely not trolling, so let's keep trying to argue against his points

  18. #18
    Grand Member Online status: silverblade5445 is offline Reputation: silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Location
    India
    Posts
    1,594

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by DaviLOTR View Post
    OP is definitely not trolling, so let's keep trying to argue against his points
    Can we please have the reason for such definitive judgement of the intention of the OP's post on your behalf?

    In my opinion,

    He -may- not be trolling, but as a forum poster, if I am having problems understanding the utility of a class/game mechanic and if I am finding it below the expectations, a more positive approach in my opinion is asking veteran players of that class/game about why am I finding this so and how am I doing it wrong and how best to improve the state of said class in a group....and to find out how those players, who CAN do it better, manage to do so....

    If I am feeling underwhelmed, I would rather ask for advice than bash the issue/class.....hence, I find the OP's post more in the lines of a troll than that of a mature meaningful discussion.....

    Ivalden - 75 Captain (R2) - Imladris
    Drankorg - Warg (R5) - Landroval

  19. #19
    Senior Member Online status: spockerized is offline Reputation: spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Anchorage, Alaska
    Posts
    640

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by silverblade5445 View Post
    a more positive approach in my opinion is asking veteran players
    who is more veteran than me?

  20. #20
    Grand Member Online status: Louvre is offline Reputation: Louvre the Neophyte Louvre the Neophyte Louvre the Neophyte Louvre the Neophyte Louvre the Neophyte Louvre the Neophyte
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Location
    Wandering in a Wargie Wonderland
    Posts
    1,163

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    While I'm of the opinion that LMs still have plenty of utility to offer in raids , I'll have to admit that I feel that while the game mechanics evolved , LMs stayed in their own private zone , same old tactics , same old skills , nothing new to offer .

    Mainly the reason why I no longer enjoy pve as much as I used to .

    r10 str / r7 wdr / r6 wvr / r6 bwr / r7 dfr
    r8 lmr / r5 rkr / r? mtr

  21. #21
    Grand Member Online status: timmyloo22546 is offline Reputation: timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Posts
    3,525

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Yeah screw LMs because burgs could just hips to exploit a certain boss in OD and then go put a fraps of the fight online while claiming server (maybe world?) first using exploit method. Totally pro!

    Anyways OP is a fail troll and likes to pay2win in the Moors. Enough said.

  22. #22
    Senior Member Online status: PsychobabbleJJ is offline Reputation: PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Location
    Australia
    Posts
    1,385

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    so your kinship has its ToO loot farm treadmill going (i'm guessing one-tank zerg on lightning t2c, one-phase zerg on acid t2c and burg-zerg on shadow t2c, one-boss zerg on F&F T2 and dps faceroll T1 sauraman) and you don't see the need to bring a non-DPS support class. That's not surprising. But if you're worried about completely optimising zerg loot farm runs, you're kinda missing the point.

    Your statement re why people haven't been able to beat sauraman/F&F T2c is completely ridiculous, those are fights with significant amount of tactical damage and in the case of sauraman P5, masses of adds, where LM debuffs are really useful.

    And the LM remains a really valuable class for kinships which don't have stuff completely on farm and who are learning their way through content. They're by far the best class for cc duty on trash pulls and fire lore/SAE gives more damage mit than a single burg. Plus, just because you can single tank lightning with a stun-immune warden (which i'm guessing is what you do), doens't mean that that's going to be an option for every kin. and if your kinship then turns around after it's learned the content and says "no LMs are coming to our farm runs because we can do them 25sec faster with an extra burg" then it's not the LM that's fail in that situation....
    Lore-mastery - A weekly column discsussing end game lore-master play.

  23. #23
    Senior Member Online status: spockerized is offline Reputation: spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Anchorage, Alaska
    Posts
    640

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by PsychobabbleJJ View Post
    so your kinship has its ToO loot farm treadmill going (i'm guessing one-tank zerg on lightning t2c, one-phase zerg on acid t2c and burg-zerg on shadow t2c, one-boss zerg on F&F T2 and dps faceroll T1 sauraman) and you don't see the need to bring a non-DPS support class. .
    Interesting point... ToO sucks point noted.

    Quote Originally Posted by PsychobabbleJJ View Post
    Your statement re why people haven't been able to beat sauraman/F&F T2c is completely ridiculous, those are fights with significant amount of tactical damage and in the case of sauraman P5, masses of adds, where LM debuffs are really useful.
    If its so useful how come no one has done it?
    Also you cant mitigate light damage which is the attacks saur does.

    http://massively.joystiq.com/2011/11...tros-update-5/

    Quote Originally Posted by PsychobabbleJJ View Post
    And the LM remains a really valuable class for kinships which don't have stuff completely on farm and who are learning their way through content.
    That's not what im talking about or making fun of people taking whatever class makeup they decide to run with. If anything I am doing those who are just about to figure it out a favor to save them the frustration and heartache of how simple the raid really is. Even in the past zerging OD AOE and range dps was good?
    Last edited by spockerized; Apr 18 2012 at 08:08 PM.

  24. #24
    Senior Member Online status: PsychobabbleJJ is offline Reputation: PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Location
    Australia
    Posts
    1,385

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by spockerized View Post
    Interesting point... ToO sucks point noted.
    I don't see how this is different from OD when we're talking about farming the raid. There's no reason to take a LM to disease other than damage mitigation which is unnecessary outside of learning the fight, a champ is better in wound, fear is do-able either with burg/hips or just overhealing, poison was 6-manned and certainly doens't need a LM, Ivar is quite possibly the exception to the rule, I'm not sure that's doable without frost lore (but why is taking a LM for one skill for one fight any less legitimate than taking it for stun immunity? how is that any less gimmicky?), and plenty of groups did gorth without a cc strategy; although, I'll concede that the wight phase would probably get pretty messy without a LM.

    When raids are on farm, specific classes become less necessary and at the end of the day you can all just stack DPS for faster kills. That isn't any sort of revelation.


    If its so useful how come no one has done it?
    Because the fights are broken and overtuned and getting nerfed. Taking one of the more useful classes out of the existing group makeups isn't going to make them any less broken. I'm sure you've read the F&F is impossible thread - that german kinship certainly doesn't see LMs as unnecessary to the strategy and they've tried a lot of different things with the fight.

    That's not what im talking about or making fun of people taking whatever class makeup they decide to run with.
    Making points just looking for good refutations.
    You're missing the point. No one is saying that LMs are the best class to zerg dps farm content with. But who cares? if you're zerg dps farming it, class makeup is irrelevant anyway so why worry about which class makeup is totally optimal? The class has a very important role during learning content and giving groups a margin for error.
    Lore-mastery - A weekly column discsussing end game lore-master play.

  25. #25
    Grand Member Online status: Tarenius is offline Reputation: Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Location
    York, UK
    Posts
    1,127

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Seems like you're just trolling, but I'll bite anyway...

    If its so useful how come no one has done it?
    Also you cant mitigate light damage which is the attacks saur does.

    http://massively.joystiq.com/2011/11...tros-update-5/
    You really believe that the reason no-one has done them is because they have a LM? If that's the case, why don't you do it without a LM and show us the screens/video?

    As I already explained to somebody else, damage type =/= damage source. I haven't tested whether you can mitigate light damage (it doesn't say so on the tactical mit tooltip, but similarly it doesn't say you can mitigate beleriand/westernesse/AD on the physical mit tooltip when in fact you can), but that is irrelevant to a debuff giving -25% tactical damage.

    .: R8 LM/Captain/Hunter/Burg/RK ~ R6 Guardian/Minstrel/Warden :.
    .: R10 WL ~ R9 Reaver/Wuarg ~ R8 Spider/BA ~ R6 Defiler :.

  26. #26
    Senior Member Online status: spockerized is offline Reputation: spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Anchorage, Alaska
    Posts
    640

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by PsychobabbleJJ View Post
    I don't see how this is different from OD when we're talking about farming the raid.
    I changed my previous post... Range and aoe dps were welcomed in OD so it was kind of different.

    Quote Originally Posted by PsychobabbleJJ View Post
    When raids are on farm, specific classes become less necessary and at the end of the day you can all just stack DPS for faster kills. That isn't any sort of revelation.
    What im arguing is that when you were learning the fights, you were doing them with 11.
    And again you prove my point unnintentially. Like many fights after it is mastered the lm is just the odd 12 and doesnt really add much... Doesnt that frustrate you?

    People seem kind of upset? Like in the back of there minds they know I'm right and just don't like the possiblity of there class being the bottom of the barrel.







    Quote Originally Posted by Tarenius View Post
    Seems like you're just trolling, but I'll bite anyway...
    ^.^
    Quote Originally Posted by Tarenius View Post
    You really believe that the reason no-one has done them is because they have a LM? If that's the case, why don't you do it without a LM and show us the screens/video?
    Im bad remember?

    Quote Originally Posted by Tarenius View Post
    but that is irrelevant to a debuff giving -25% tactical damage.
    Seriously tho on saur put frostlore on it at phase 3 to phase 5 and keep track of the damage.. Its not actually being reduced by 25% Run it one week without it and keep tabs everytime he does the light attack and 1 week keep it on it and keep tabs.
    Last edited by spockerized; Apr 18 2012 at 08:19 PM.

  27. #27
    Senior Member Online status: PsychobabbleJJ is offline Reputation: PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Location
    Australia
    Posts
    1,385

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by spockerized View Post
    I changed my previous post... Range and aoe dps were welcomed in OD so it was kind of different.
    Well as you say (and it was even more true at 65) LM single target ranged DPS is useless so I'll assume you're talking about the one, single, fight with ranged AOE DPS - and please explain to me how a LM is better than a champ for Wound T2? Becuase if you're doing it properly, you're pulling the adds fast enough that champs will be doing much more DPS than loremasters - loremasters only out-DPS champs in burst.


    What im arguing is that when you were learning the fights, you were doing them with 11.
    And again you prove my point unnintentially. Like many fights after it is mastered the lm is just the odd 12 and doesnt really add much... Doesnt that frustrate you?
    no, it's not right. because EVERY class is replaceable once you've learned the fight and got it on farm. Everyone's useless, no one's a special snowflake. The ONLY time specific classes and abilities have genuine unique uses is when you're learning content. I don't know what more you want from a class really, we are vitally important during the only time that class makeup actually matters in this game. Raids in this game have never been so unforgiving that at farm level, once everyone's figured the mechanics out, you still need to come along with the absolutely perfect class makeup and all be super on top of your game. The only time class optimisation matters is while learning.
    Lore-mastery - A weekly column discsussing end game lore-master play.

  28. #28
    Senior Member Online status: spockerized is offline Reputation: spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Anchorage, Alaska
    Posts
    640

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by PsychobabbleJJ View Post
    Well as you say (and it was even more true at 65) LM single target ranged DPS is useless so I'll assume you're talking about the one, single, fight with ranged AOE DPS - and please explain to me how a LM is better than a champ for Wound T2? Becuase if you're doing it properly, you're pulling the adds fast enough that champs will be doing much more DPS than loremasters - loremasters only out-DPS champs in burst.
    Champs sucked in OD
    Remember at 75 champs finally got a buff.

    Quote Originally Posted by PsychobabbleJJ View Post
    no, it's not right. because EVERY class is replaceable once you've learned the fight and got it on farm.
    being Useful and relavant are two different things. Remember my initial points. Sure you can replace a dps with any other dps whatever. I'm arguing you offer the bare minimum.

    To me it sounds like you are in denial and have some invested interest in the class? Like im attacking your livelyhood or something. Cheer up buttercup.

  29. #29
    Grand Member Online status: Tarenius is offline Reputation: Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend Tarenius the Bounders-friend
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Location
    York, UK
    Posts
    1,127

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Psychobabble has pretty much said everything. I don't disagree that once you have stuff on farm mode LMs are replaceable... So what? Finishing your 2 hour raid 5 minutes earlier really isn't important. It also dpends on your strategy I suppose... We have the LM chain mez 2 mobs during shadow HM, you would need 2 burgs to do that & they loose lots of DPS for the ability to do so (they have to use mischief, i.e no bonus from QK stance and no FA).

    For the learning process, LMs are invaluable. If they were as useless as you suggest & an extra burg was more useful, people simply would not take them. That exact thing happened with Wardens... Guardians generally did the same job but better, so very few raid groups used Wardens.

    .: R8 LM/Captain/Hunter/Burg/RK ~ R6 Guardian/Minstrel/Warden :.
    .: R10 WL ~ R9 Reaver/Wuarg ~ R8 Spider/BA ~ R6 Defiler :.

  30. #30
    Senior Member Online status: spockerized is offline Reputation: spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Anchorage, Alaska
    Posts
    640

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by Tarenius View Post
    We have the LM chain mez 2 mobs during shadow HM, you would need 2 burgs to do that & they loose lots of DPS for the ability to do so.
    You can use whatever strategy you want. I am still arguing they are the bottom of the barrel. Again some points I am claiming. Irrelavency of debuffs. Lack of DPs. Again just a 12th spot, but like you said the 12th spot can be anyone at this point it doesn't matter. I am arguing that it should and the lm isnt there.

    Quote Originally Posted by Tarenius View Post
    That exact thing happened with Wardens... Guardians generally did the same job but better, so very few raid groups used Wardens.
    Ding ding ding now you are starting to understand.

  31. #31
    Senior Member Online status: PsychobabbleJJ is offline Reputation: PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend PsychobabbleJJ the Bounders-friend
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Location
    Australia
    Posts
    1,385

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by spockerized View Post
    Champs sucked in OD
    Remember at 75 champs finally got a buff.
    no, champs were good in the one fight in OD that you are saying proved that LMs were usefull in OD. By your reasoning, LMs were about equal with champs for usefulness in OD.
    Lore-mastery - A weekly column discsussing end game lore-master play.

  32. #32
    Senior Member Online status: spockerized is offline Reputation: spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Anchorage, Alaska
    Posts
    640

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by PsychobabbleJJ View Post
    no, champs were good in the one fight in OD that you are saying proved that LMs were usefull in OD. By your reasoning, LMs were about equal with champs for usefulness in OD.
    And that 1 fight you rather stack champs than Lms. And everyone knew champs were bad in OD.. Only proves my point that lms are the bottom of the barrel.
    Looks like you are trying to hangon to some last refuge. Finding any means necessary to maintain that peace of mind.
    Keep digging you might find something.

  33. #33
    Century Member Online status: Asterotg is offline Reputation: Asterotg the Neutral
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    117

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    If I follow your argument, only one tank and two healers are essential. Why bother with the rest of the classes, because a good raid uses the bonuses of all classes.

    No reason to argue with someone who has made up his mind and is immune to reasoning.


    lvl 85 lm (main), lvl 85 champ, lvl 85 rk, lvl 85 hunter

  34. #34
    Senior Member Online status: spockerized is offline Reputation: spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary spockerized the Wary
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Anchorage, Alaska
    Posts
    640

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by Asterotg View Post
    If I follow your argument, only one tank and two healers are essential.
    That's just idiotic.
    Quote Originally Posted by Asterotg View Post
    Why bother with the rest of the classes, because a good raid uses the bonuses of all classes.
    Again I'm arguing with the lm its not enough.

    Quote Originally Posted by Asterotg View Post
    No reason to argue with someone who has made up his mind and is immune to reasoning.
    I'm looking and so far all I got is that it makes the trash easier ~_~ see the problem I have here?

  35. #35
    Senior Member Online status: Widoch is offline Reputation: Widoch the Watcher of Roads Widoch the Watcher of Roads Widoch the Watcher of Roads Widoch the Watcher of Roads Widoch the Watcher of Roads Widoch the Watcher of Roads Widoch the Watcher of Roads Widoch the Watcher of Roads Widoch the Watcher of Roads Widoch the Watcher of Roads Widoch the Watcher of Roads
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Posts
    434

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    I've never played a LM but I do have this one little thing to add. I've been in instances before where the LM being able to recharge a healing mini or RK or a tanking guardian who's out of power when the poop hits the fan has saved our butts before.

  36. #36
    Poster of Note Online status: DuneBug is offline Reputation: DuneBug the Neophyte DuneBug the Neophyte DuneBug the Neophyte DuneBug the Neophyte DuneBug the Neophyte DuneBug the Neophyte
    Join Date
    Dec 2010
    Posts
    720

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    LM's are plenty useful. If there is a problem with the class it is that they don't stack well so bringing more than one is a liability. And because debuffs are what is most preferred in raids, and because sticky gourd creates lag issues, yellow line is pretty much you're only choice for raiding.

    It's hard to pass up debuffs when you're a raid leader. Even on farm nights the choice is ... do I want my healers to have to heal 20% more, for a marginal dps increase (probably 1000) and maybe risk a few unnecessary wipes?

    I'll admit ToO is a dps-fest compared to OD... but that is more a factor of poor raid design than a referendum on the lore-master.
    It's the same reason champs are fervour tanking some of the raid bosses and nobody's beaten two of the wings.

    85 (Captain, Champion, Guardian)

  37. #37
    Senior Member Online status: Kraggy_Eldar is offline Reputation: Kraggy_Eldar has disabled reputation
    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    129

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by spockerized View Post
    I just don't see a use for them..
    Your loss.

  38. #38
    Grand Member Online status: timmyloo22546 is offline Reputation: timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads timmyloo22546 the Watcher of Roads
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Posts
    3,525

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by DuneBug View Post
    I'll admit ToO is a dps-fest compared to OD... but that is more a factor of poor raid design than a referendum on the lore-master.
    It's the same reason champs are fervour tanking some of the raid bosses and nobody's beaten two of the wings.
    Definately. Same with adaption. I actually preferred the adaption mechanic in OD compared to ToO.

  39. #39
    Senior Member Online status: Marphlets is offline Reputation: Marphlets the Wary Marphlets the Wary Marphlets the Wary
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Location
    West Coast, USA
    Posts
    153

    Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    While I'm glad to see new and lively discussion on the LM forums, the "Are Loremasters Useful" arguement? Seriously?! We've done this.

    Maybe the OP was a) frustrated about the new update play or maybe b) he is just a fail troll (in case of b, stop feeding it) - but please, let's just play the game, have fun and get over ourselves and our respective classes.

    I'll tell you what's useless - having this tired old debate. . .again.

    Mamakas - L80 Minstrel(Gladden), Izora - L55 Guardian(Riddermark)

  40. #40
    Grand Member Online status: silverblade5445 is offline Reputation: silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads silverblade5445 the Watcher of Roads
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Location
    India
    Posts
    1,594

    Thumbs up Re: The LM Just isn't Useful Anymore!

    Quote Originally Posted by Marphlets View Post
    I'll tell you what's useless - having this tired old debate. . .again.
    QFT indeed

    Ivalden - 75 Captain (R2) - Imladris
    Drankorg - Warg (R5) - Landroval

+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts