Now nothing wrong with Hornblower's Pies, but Steak and Kidney (L20), Perfect (L30), Spiced Apple (L30), Bilberry (L66), Cottage (L66), Chicken (L75) and Apple and Cheese Pies (L75) are good as well. Pie lotteries by level could be a nice touch, or a lottery for a veritable Pie Overload Bonanza (perhaps hobbits-only?) could be awesome...
(as a Person on a Diet in the so-called Real World, LOTRO pies are about all I am allowed ).