Thread: Kinship Revamp Proposal

Kinship Revamp

Month of the kinship seems like a distant memory now, however, there's so much potential to improve the current kin system I think it deserves to be explored. Why?
Social interaction within an MMO is one of the most important factors of the gameplay, if it wasn't we may aswell be playing any random single-player game. One of the most common ways to communicate with other players in-game is through joining a kinship. Here you are able to chat with one another, organise events, and really enjoy the online aspect of the game.
At present the kinship system in Lotro is Ok, it provides players the most important feature - kin chat. However, the system can be evolved to something greater that will really help unite kinship members towards a common goal.

Objectives:
- To increase the reasons for joining a kinship
- To encourage players within a kin to work together
- To provide players with rewards for their efforts as a kin
- To increase the options available to kin members and officers
- Update the kinship UI so it's in-keeping with more recent UI changes
- To provide Turbine with a source of income to help fund the cost of the revamp.

The User Interface:
Before setting off into the methods we can use to improve the kinship system, I thought I would kick it off with how I envision the UI to be and how the components will all fit together. As this post is going to be image-heavy I feel it would be best to describe what you are seeing before jumping into the details.

Roster with player note:

(Updated with store buttons).

Roster with officer note:

So you see we have a menu down the left side, here you have the kin's rank, how much money is in the kins bank account, menu options to bring up different screens, and the normal invite, remove, promote, and demote buttons. Some things will be very desirable such as the kin bank and option to increase MotD size, these could be sold as store perks.

Roster:

The roster is where you will find most of the information from the current kin system, so the kin name, message of the day, and the list of players.
The most helpful update to this is a wider member list which will display the player note alongside the rest of the information. I don't know about other kins, but we mainly use the player notes to list our alts and mains so we always know who is who. By bringing the player note to the main window it just makes it that little bit easier to identify.

I think it would also be helpful to have officer notes. Something that can be set by officers with the necessary permissions. This would be a beneficial tool for officers to communicate with one another over particular members, whether it's to highlight someone who is in need of help with something, or someone who has been causing problems.

I have also designed the UI with a larger message of the day box. At the moment it can be a struggle to fit much in there, so more space would be great.

One other suggestion for the UI from a kin leader perspective is an added store button to change the name of the kin.. I know this was a premium service at one point, not sure if it still is, but being able to rename the kin through the store would be helpful to a select few.

Other than that, for the roster view, I just wanted to move things about a bit and make it less cluttered.


Next I'm going to jump down the menu to..

Ranks:

At present we have 5 ranks within the kinship system, taking out the leader and successor we really only have 3 ranks that we can play around with. It would be great to see this doubled with editable permissions for each rank. These additional ranks could be sold in the store.

I think that most of this is self-explanatory, there may be some that don't make sense now but they should do by the end of this post. Even if all this gets pushed aside and we never see any further ranks added, it would be great to at least set permissions for each chest in the kin house (whether through the kinship panel as above or through the housing permissions window). As a kin leader, I would love to be able to set aside one chest for officer use only.

I feel it's important to have more ranks and to be able to edit the permissions so we can have more control over our kin members and what they are able to do within the kin. At present we can't really do that. If we want someone to recruit for example we have to make them an officer, which gives them access to a lot of other permissions we may not want that particular person to have.

edit: I recently changed this design to allow players to customise the rank names and titles (the kin title that is displayed if the player wants to display their kin rank as their character title). This was suggested in some of the replies to this post and would be handy for different themed kins to devise their own names and titles.


Log:

This is something that will be a huge asset to the kin system, as a method of tracking kin activity. Whether this is a security measure or just a way to celebrate recent member successes which we may not otherwise know about.

The log will have filter options across the top to quickly help you find what you are looking for.
The log itself will be made up from:
- Promotion/Demotion activity
- New members
- Players who have left the kin
- Mile-stone level advancement of each player (10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 65)
- Deposits made to the kin bank
- Withdrawals from the kin bank and why
- Deposits to the kin housing containers
- Withdrawals from the kin housing containers
- Blessings that have been earned by the kin
- Kin quests that have been accepted
- Kin quests that have been completed

This will give officers a much greater way of knowing what has been going on in the kin while they haven't been playing.
Permissions for who can view the log will be settable for each rank.

Kin bank:

This will give kin members a chance to pool together money to use for things like paying house maintenance, buying house items, buying items for kin events, and any other ideas players may have (lottery ftw!).

Players will be able to contribute at any time from the kinship panel, by clicking the button which will pop up a new window:

This will work similar to sending money in the post.. you enter how much of each coin you want to contribute and that's it.

Players will be able to withdraw money (depending on permissions) to spend on the kin. Of course there is a security risk here, but it will be down to the kin leaders to decide who will have permissions to use this feature, and the log will keep track should any money start to mysteriously disappear.

To withdraw you will have to supply a reason which will go down in the log for everyone else to see.

Having a kin bank may not be the top priority, but it sure would be awesome.. At the moment I have to keep my kins money in a separate character so I don't confuse it with my own.. I'm sure plenty of other people do the same.. A kin bank would help in so many ways. Also, kin members may be more generous if they can see where the money is going.


One great thing we can do for sure with this kin bank is link it to the kinship house's maintenance and have it as the default for paying upkeep.

(A brief update to the mail system):

As you can only put 4 images to each post I thought I'd sly this one in here.
With the new ranks and permissions, it would be helpful if we had an option to send a mail to officers only - this would work like the current kin mail system, but the mail would go to officers (with the permission set of course) only. Also, an increase in attachment size whilst we're at it.

Kin Quests:

This is where I want to encourage players to work as a team to meet kin-wide objectives.

With this UI we have the current active quest at the top, showing the objectives and rewards.. We then have the leaderboard, which will show the ranks of all the kin members for the current quest, and all the quests. This leaderboard will only be visible to kin ranks with the set permission to view. The reason for this is that some leaders may want to know how each player is taking part, but perhaps not want to encourage competition from members by hiding the leaderboard from their view.

Rewards:

As you can see from the quest above, there would be a new barter token, Medallion of Affinity.. I probably could have made this anything, or just used a point system, but Medallions seem to be the way forward.

(Yes I do have too much time on my hands - although I wouldn't mind a job offer from Turbine *hint hint*)

These Medallions will be bound to the kinship, they will not appear anywhere in your inventory (huzzah!). This means you won't be able to spend them on personal loot, they will be used only for items you can use for your kinship. You will see more about this in a bit.

Quests:

Out of all of this revamp proposal, I feel this would be the toughest area to overcome.. taking into account the original objective to unite the players of the kin towards a common goal, what kind of quest could be offered that could do this.. that also must be achievable by players of all level.

In the above example the objective is to defeat 1000 monsters in Dol Guldur. This would be an obvious style of quest. Where every member in the kin will contribute towards this objective. However I wouldn't expect every quest to be a slayer quest otherwise people will get bored. Also, the system needs to take into account that some kins may be new, formed by low level players.. So the quests available need to cater for them too.

I would perhaps group the quests under different headings, offering the kin the chance to do one quest from each heading per week.

Also, only one quest will be active at a time, and the quests will have a one week cooldown.. also in terms of slayer quests, it would be important to make grey monsters not count towards the objective - this way players will have to focus on monsters their own level. Perhaps quest cooldowns could be reduced through a store purchase.

Another type of quest which will be accessible to most players would be to utilise the skirmish system, where instances that scale from 20-65 can be run x amount of times by everyone in the kin.. but again, the instance level would have to be within your level range for your contribution to count.

When I have more time to really think about the quests I will add more in.

Deeds:

As well as having kin quests, we could also have deeds.. The quests would offer the medallions needed to rank up blessings.. Deeds on the other hand could award titles and kin cosmetics for example.

Here are some examples.. They don't just have to be slayer deeds, but could also be awarded for raid success, craft success, or perhaps taking part in a festival food event such as pie eating. In the case of slayer or raid deeds - the numbers seem high but this is because it would count per person in the raid - so for example for 'Complete the ten guards 180 times' deed, in a raid of 12 kin members, completing this challenge will increase the deed 12 times, once per person.


Cosmetics:

Kin Cosmetics would allow selected ranks in the kin to create a kin outfit that members could select from a new cosmetic option in their character window.

So you can see that you could select the different ranks at the top, each rank could have its own outfit.. If you wanted them the same however you could set the outfit for one rank, and then copy it for the rest using the option at the bottom of the window.

I thought perhaps there would also be room for a wardrobe to store select clothing items, this way other players in the kin can contribute an item that could be added to the look at a later date, with this there's also an opportunity for Turbine to sell more storage. Any cosmetic items received for completing a kin deed would also be automatically stored here.

Cosmetics would only be changeable by those ranks with permissions set.

Alliance:

Based off the response to this thread and other threads on the forum I wanted adjust this proposal to include some sort of alliance system and a calendar with events planner.

This is a mock up of how an alliance system could work.. I based this on a three-way alliance. It could be adapted to allow for more kins, but I think 3 is a pretty solid number. Each kin would be listed with its name, leader, and up to three selected officers who would automatically be allowed to set the messages in the alliance notice board, and they would also be able to create alliance events through their own kins calendar.

An alliance will be formed when a kin leader invites another kin leader to join an alliance, by default the originating player will become the alliance leader.. The alliance leader will be the only one who can invite an additional kin or disband the alliance.

The leader will also have the option to merge the alliance kins into one kin (by default the alliance kins will fold into the alliance leaders kin - to change this the alliance leader would have to resign). I have seen in the past that some alliance kins end up getting a strong enough bond to fold into each other and form one kin, at present the only way to do this is to leave one kin and be invite to the other, but there's a good chance of some players going missing. This way it's all handled automatically so everyone gets transferred across, at the same time. If the old kin has a house then the items would be placed in escrow storage.
A system would have to be in place however to prevent a merge from happening if it would result in more members than the kin can handle.. Perhaps a pop-up saying that your kin can only have 1,500 members and that there are too many members for a merge - then the kin leaders will have to decide maybe if they want to stay as they are or remove some old inactive members to make room.

I tried to demonstrate the three kin panels to show the various options that could be available.

One thing not mentioned here is that the kins will have access to the alliance channel - this will be a new channel that players in each kin will be able to use instead of needing to create their own channel. If anyone leaves one of the kins then they automatically lose access to this specific alliance channel, no need to worry about people being in the channel you may not want.


Calendar:

The calendar will allow your kin and alliance to organise events, hopefully with no need for an extra raid planner.

Permissions to add, edit, and delete events will be set in the ranks window.. If your kin is in an alliance, the alliance officers you select will automatically have rights to these permissions. When posting an event they will have the option to share it with the alliance. Shared events will then show up in all two or three kins calendars and allow each member to sign up.

You can view who has signed up at any time by clicking a raid and pressing the view button.

This would be a great help for organising events between alliances and through kins that want to raid occasionally but can't necessarily get the traffic to their forums. The only downside is that this won't feature any loot systems such as DKP or SK. Those would still have to be maintained manually.


Blessings:

"The world is changing.. A great shadow is spreading from the East. Sauron has returned. He can't yet take physical form but with the ring of power, he will regain his strength. He is seeking it so desperately. Everywhere across Middle-Earth his loyal followers are gathering. Your kinship has seen it. From the icy heights of Forochel, right across to the borders of Lothlorien. They unite for one thing, to capture the ring and cover the world in darkness.

Your kinship however is one thing they did not expect. A team of heroes such as yourselves uniting against them to protect the mission of the fellowship. Already you have achieved so much but I fear the greatest battles are still ahead. To aid you in this I will bestow upon your kinship the blessings of the Eldar. May they help your kinship lead the free peoples of Middle Earth to their victory."

When you complete a kin quest your kin will earn Medallions of Affinity. On the blessing screen is where your officers can spend those Medallions.
Originally I designed 7 banners that could be used in groups, but I have recently updated it based on the feedback in this thread to allow for personal rewards as well so those kins that are more casual can enjoy this system too. The banners would work like an item that can be dragged from the UI to your quickslots, and then placed when needed. The personal rewards would work alongside the trait system. Once the kin has earnt those personal rewards they will appear in the trait trainer window for you to slot.

The group banners all Rank from 1 to 5. You have to earn rank 1 before you can use that banner, the cost for each rank will be shown above. In the UI you can see for example that the last banner on the top row is Rank 0 (unearned), so to be able to use this banner at Rank 1 an officer would have to spend 25 medallions from the kins total. Once earned any kin member will be able to use the banner when in a fellowship or raid. They could do this by either clicking the 'Use' button, or by dragging the banner to their quickslots for faster access.
The current rank of the banner is shown in the icon.

Rank costs:
1 = 25 Medallions
2 = 50 Medallions
3 = 100 Medallions
4 = 150 Medallions
5 = 200 Medallions

I did consider if the banners should be one-use only, but I don't think that would be a fair reward for the grind that will need to be done to rank them all up.
One thing that should be important is that only one banner can be placed at a time. So in a raid, if one person places the banner of offence and someone else later places the banner of hope, the banner of offence will despawn, otherwise you'd end up with kins using all the banners in a raid which would be insane.

Banners:

The benefits are based on the assumption that most people using them will be at the level cap.. however the benefits would scale depending on the level of the individual player.

(Edit: Some of these banners have been introduced through the LotRO store since this post was made as personal buffs. If this update ever makes it into the game then I suspect these kinship/personal buffs would be reviewed.)

Of all the banners, Kinship Banner of Ascension is my personal favourite.. chucking one of those down before a wipe would save so much time.

Personal Rewards:

The personal blessings will be similar to traits, once an officer has ranked a blessing up to one it will appear in the trait trainer window for you to slot into a new trait section.. I have reworked the trait window a little to demonstrate how they will appear once they are slotted..

and also a new 'Blessings' tab which will show you what blessings are available to you and the current ranks..

With the help of the suggestions in this thread I put together 10 personal blessings as a starter, most of them are just out-of-combat benefits such as run speed, XP, map CD etc. I thought it would be good to allow up to 2 blessings slotted at a time. One just looked silly on its own, and three would be too much of a benefit.

Blessings: (This image will likely be shrunk but you can drag it to a new tab or save it to view in full)

I think that's it..

I hope you all like the suggestion and fingers crossed for some development.
I will keep you posted if I think of anything else.

Feel free to post comments or any other suggestions you may have.. and thanks for sticking with me to the end of the post if you managed to read it all - huzzah cookies for you

I'm assuming you've blocked out all the posts you think you'll need to wrap this up, but at about the halfway mark as of this writing, I like most if not all of what I'm seeing. I would like to see Turbine take a serious second (or third, or eighth) look at Kinships, starting with what you're starting with; a clear set of tools that players can only access by joining or forming a Kinship.

With the pictures, it looks so much better than our current kin system
Turbine seriously needs to look at their kinship system

I really like the cleanliness of your ideas and all the additions, like extra ranks, and kinship back, etc

/signed

Love the ideas. Deeds/quests for kin-only, to give greater benefit to the membership.

Love the graphics.

+2 for the ideas.

+2 for the work you've put into this.

Thanks everyone for your comments so far.. as some of you posted while I was still writing I thought I'd take the opportunity to let you know that I have now finished, and you can read the post in it's entirety

You have done an awesome job here. Many of the ideas you have put forward are ones that I have wished for and IMO are actually essential to a good kinship system and should have really been included from the get go (like the ability to control rank permissions). I'd like to add one of my own wishes here and ask that they allow us to create custom ranks and rename all the ranks to reflect a kinships concept. An added perk is that some of these ideas could be incorporated into the store and provide an added incentive for Turbine to actually consider them.

The downside is that Turbine takes forever to make any such changes and often won't even consider them. This next update they have mentioned including changes to the housing system. Although I haven't heard anything specific yet about them. It took years to get them to make any changes to the clunky housing system ... sigh ...

This is one of the best posts I've seen regarding (needed) kinship updates. I really like all of the suggested changes, and the layout looks very good as well.

+rep to you.

Since I have already voiced very similar ideas in my own posts, I heartily agree with what you are suggesting. Unlike what I posted, you also added amazing pictures which really help force the point. I do have to disagree with the banners though because they replace buff classes like the captain.

/signed

+rep for the wonderfully detailed post. The proposed interfaces also looked excellent. Turbine would be crazy not to take these ideas into consideration if they haven't already.

Dude, like . . . seriously . . . You should submit your resume to Turbine.

Love the ideas you posted here!

Awesome presentation of a nicely fleshed out idea. Good job and I hope the devs consider this.

./bump

Originally Posted by Deyjarl

And your Blessings idea (and a lot of the other ideas) look a lot, if not almost exactly like Warhammer Online's system except for different graphics. Do you really have to copy it that blatantly?

Sorry, I've never played Warhammer Online let alone cared enough to look into it. It's my understanding that there's probably a few MMOs that have improved kinship functionality such as kinship questing. By adding in questing there needs to be some reward and I went with blessing after considering different names because I felt it would be more lore appropriate.

Someone else also posted about the banners replacing a captain. This wouldn't be so. This is something I thought about, and I don't think any of the banners could provide as much benefit as having a captain in the group. I tried to restrict the banners to two bonuses each, this way captain banners plus their buff skills such as Idome etc will still be far superior. The banners will allow for a little bonus on top of whatever the captain gives, they will also allow kins who maybe struggle to get a captain to enjoy some benefits.

Well presented suggestion to improve the actual worth and usefulness of Kinships.

wow, great work. +rep for you!

the only thing i dont like is the banners. i think they could make some content too easy for kin raids and the revive one i def think could be very overpowered

Turbine! ??? are you waiting for? Hire this person right now...........STAT!

I'm mostly opposed to "Enchourageing" people to join kinships. it tends to dischourage people from not joining. a kinship should be a group of like minded individuals and friends, not a buncha people joined together by a common need to get ahead

Originally Posted by BrianDavion

I'm mostly opposed to "Enchourageing" people to join kinships. it tends to dischourage people from not joining. a kinship should be a group of like minded individuals and friends, not a buncha people joined together by a common need to get ahead

That's a fair enough comment. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion on this. However I wouldn't say kin questing would be required, it would have appeal to some kins that do want to get ahead, where as for others they could chose to ignore it. Either way, the option would be there.

Originally Posted by Deyjarl

Again they should hire the Developer of the Warhammer Online guild system, because that is where he stole this idea from whole sale.

Think what you will, at no point in my post have I stated that it was my idea. There's nothing new in my suggestion, I'm sure plenty of MMOs provide similar kinship functionality - kin banks, logs, questing and rewards... Ground breaking.

The main point of this thread was to adapt these systems for lotro, and I wanted to introduce it with a UI that I designed to best showcase the suggestion.

I maintain that I have never played Warhammer online, if the UI looks the same then it's a coincidence. Whether you believe me or not is up to you, it makes no difference to me in the slightest.

Original or derivative the ideas presented would be an exponential improvement of the current kinship model.

Now for the cold water:

Given the current game business model I imagine any idea requiring developer cost/time will need to pay for itself via the store.

It isn't ideal but I am guessing Turbine will give it consideration if you can also demonstrate how improving kinships will make them money.

That means, perhaps, banners having an in-game and store version, I think people will get where I am going.

At this point the premise that more people will play, or play more and buy/spend points isn't enough in light of the legendary updates on bullroarer.

Originally Posted by Galuhad

That's a fair enough comment. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion on this. However I wouldn't say kin questing would be required, it would have appeal to some kins that do want to get ahead, where as for others they could chose to ignore it. Either way, the option would be there.

except I'm afraid the option would swiftly turn into anything BUT an Option.
I'm just a little gunshy of such an idea after funcom's disasterous guild reknown system over in age of conan. that basicly generated an enviroment that was basicly hostile to smallish RP guilds.

I suppose though that turbine'd be able to do a slightly better set up as I suspect their office copy boy has a better head for MMO design then Funcom

I agree with everything except for kinship banners.

What about Pugs? Or alliances? How would you fit those?

Excellent work on everything else!

Originally Posted by Maldrake

The downside is that Turbine takes forever to make any such changes and often won't even consider them. This next update they have mentioned including changes to the housing system. Although I haven't heard anything specific yet about them. It took years to get them to make any changes to the clunky housing system ... sigh ...

I have a feeling Turbine is seriously understaffed. Hopefully with the increased revenue from F2P, they can hire a few more bodies and set them on specific large-scale tasks, such as housing and kinship revamps.

Originally Posted by Deyjarl

Again they should hire the Developer of the Warhammer Online guild system, because that is where he stole this idea from whole sale.

Stop your whining. It is not at all similar.

Originally Posted by BrianDavion

I suppose though that turbine'd be able to do a slightly better set up as I suspect their office copy boy has a better head for MMO design then Funcom

Hey! Anarchy Online was a lot of fun ... up until they decided to add fantasy to the sci-fi theme with the Shadowlands expansion.

Instead of BANNERS, rather an Kinship trait page on our character TRAITS window would be better.

You can trait up to TWO traits that the Kinship has earned (from a wide variety, via deeds, quests, etc.) Perhaps the Kinship traits also have ranks (ala Virtues traits).

So basically we'd have Virtue traits, Class traits, Race traits, Legendary traits, and Kinship traits. The Kinship traits are the available pool of traits that the kinship has earned, and you can choose to slot two of them.

definitely should do this, its been way too long since they've expanded on kinship stuff, i more then anything would like the diversity of ranks with the ability to edit the permissions of each group. Also like the kin quests, the log tracking whats taken out of the kin chests, the bank being linked to kin house upkeep, the rewards for kin quests.

Very nice job, and presentation should be considered by turbine as template for their revamp on kinships.

And what someone else said what would make it better is a implementation of alliances, I know i would love that move of a global chat for alliances, or a roster at least of the kins telling whose online.

Originally Posted by Chiot

Instead of BANNERS, rather an Kinship trait page on our character TRAITS window would be better.

You can trait up to TWO traits that the Kinship has earned (from a wide variety, via deeds, quests, etc.) Perhaps the Kinship traits also have ranks (ala Virtues traits).

So basically we'd have Virtue traits, Class traits, Race traits, Legendary traits, and Kinship traits. The Kinship traits are the available pool of traits that the kinship has earned, and you can choose to slot two of them.

That is a better implementation of the banner thing.

One thing i would like to add. Instead of battle advantages, the kinship traits should focus on social or financial aspect of lotro. Like lower cost on travel or vendor discounts in selected zones in which you have some reputation.

It is beautiful. Good job.

The only problem I see is that the buffs are Over Powered. Turbine will balance content especially group content on the assumption that every one in the instance has the highest Kin Buffs. You are not in kin that fully ranked up in the Buff area. You can not do the content.

Essentially all players will be need to join very large kins to get the benefits. It will wipe out all the smaller kins on the Servers. You will get back to the monster kins like the one I belonged to in Asheron's Call that had over 10,000 members. I was a second tier officer with about 600 people to keep track off. There were perhaps 2,000 under my patron who was directly under the Monarch.

Solo players would be left out completely. Depending on the how buffs are applied. All content in the game may be upped in difficulty on the assumption everybody has these buffs. It was the raiders in Moria with Hope gear rolling all none raid content including landscape that resulted in the creation of Gloom and Radiance. Removal of Hope from the instance gear. Turbine felt constant +5 Hope was way OP.

Whilst I agree with most of the OP's objectives, I would be against any "playing" advantage of being in a Kin.
Some people are in RL "loners" and probably play a game such as this very happily solo.
The reason I am, in effect not in a Kin is becauseI have two of my own, with me the only member. I have these kins because there is so much gold in the game the cost and maintenance is negligeable compared to my income, I can cover the rent of both in maybe an hours play, and I just love the fluff and wanted the big houses!!!
I was in a great Kin, and it was their well furnished hall made me want one, so I left and formed my own purely to get the Kin Hall !!

I agree with the concerns about the buffs. Other than that I have only two words to say:

YES PLEASE

The banners were just an example of what could be done to offer reward for kin questing. This of course could be anything. With regards to the buffs being over-powered, I did consider this, however I was under the assumption that if this update ever happened it wouldn't be until isengard in which case the level cap would be higher anyway.
The idea of being able to use kin rewards as personal traits would work too, however I think which ever idea some will be happy whilst others won't. The reason I would prefer a benefit item for grouping is because I imagine the quests needed to get these items would encourage grouping. So in this respect your kin works as a group to do the quests and would get group perks for it.

I also appreciate that some kins will be smaller and more casual, in this case banners may not be the best reward. Perhaps personal traits offering buffs like run speed, map CD, item xp etc, may be more preferred.

The solution could then be that banners and traits are offered as reward? The banners can deal with the combat side of rewards, while the personal trait can deal with the more personal fun rewards. Either way your kin would have to earn medallions to rank up those traits/banners. Just casual kins could chose a quest that can be completed through solo play, such as killing x amount of something.. A quest that wouldn't need any specific work to achieve other than standard play.

Very nicely done, Your system looks great as far as revamping kinships go, im dying for the allowance of player-made titles and more ranks within kin ranks.

Very solid, bravo!

You forgot to sprinkle some of the “buy now” buttons over the interface, tsk tsk tsk.

Additional thoughts:

Timezone info/conversion in the member-rooster.


How about rewards like options to port kin-members, use would be more for spontaneous help somewhere out in the wildernis or RP events outside regular traffic routes.

Other rewards could be also more in terms of cosmetic clothing, special emotes (different bow/salute for example that could accommodate the “spirit” of the kin).

Could even be a special mount, not obtainable otherwise?

Perhaps instead of the blessings/banner more a kin-item which usage is comparable to a fellowship maneuver, maybe more powerful but high cd so that it’s only usable once in a run or even per day? Only a few different types available and unique – could lead to problems though if kins are too big and have more than one run at the same time.

Originally Posted by Galuhad

The banners were just an example of what could be done to offer reward for kin questing. This of course could be anything. With regards to the buffs being over-powered, I did consider this, however I was under the assumption that if this update ever happened it wouldn't be until isengard in which case the level cap would be higher anyway.

I would not waste any effort on trying to flesh out the rewards. Turbine is more than capable of dealing with the reward side in a manner that fits properly into the rest of the game systems. Plus not make small kins and loners left behind due to not having access to the game play advantages.

Based on posts that have been pruned Turbine seems to use the following design. For each character level - they decide the maximum total stat points you can get. Our characters are not allowed to get over that maximum.

The next thing they do is balance the differences based on acquisition methods. You will not see a massive difference between quest, crafted and instance gear as far stats are concerned when comparing gear for the same level character. AL will differ based on light, medium and heavy.

Many things are ratings. They are capped to make sure no one can get over the character limit. Which might be 5%. When I put my Relentless Attack Buff on a level 10 - they do not the full rating benefit like a peer level 65 will.

For many buffs, they do not want people getting permanent buffs. It is temporary like Hope Tokens. On good as long as you are grouped with a Captain or close enough to the class member to be under the buff aura.

This game is about a lot of very small benefits. There are very few ways to get big benefits. Captains have one of the few big benefits. They can plunk down a Banner of War, 10% mark, Oathbreakers and boost the damage output of their shield buddy. One group member can go RAAAWWWWR for a few seconds. The rest of the group gets a RAWR. Then it dies down to a plain Rawr.

Originally Posted by Deyjarl

There is no possible way you could accidentally copy it as much as you have. And there are no other games that have all that you copied from Warhammer Online for you to have collected it from other games.

Again, shame on you, you should give proper credit to the source of the information you have blatantly copied.

Ok, so let's compare then.. Taking info from the website you linked earlier:
http://www.warherald.com/warherald/N...cle.war?id=167

The Kinship Interface I proposed..



The Interface from that website above..






(right away the interfaces are completely different)


So Warhammer has -
Profile showing message of the day, guild news, and by the looks of it someone's email address..
Lotro already uses message of the day so I suppose you should harass Turbine for stealing that idea themselves..
Guild news would be similar to the log I put in to the UI, though this is nothing new. People on these forums have been asking for a log for years, ever since people could use kin housing as a way to store items. From what I understand, other MMOs use a log system too for recording kin data (WoW for example).. I added to the log ideas that I thought would be useful, given that I have been leader of the same kin for 2.5 years, I have my own ideas of the information I would like to see.. Undoubtedly some of these will be the same as those logs in other MMOs, there's only so much information you can put into them after all.

Calendar showing raid info and sign-ups.. Oops seems I forgot this one, how silly of me.

Roster listing the kin members. I wonder if Warhammer own's exclusive rights to the usage of the word Roster.. I admit, the idea came to me from EQDKPs use of the word roster for listing all the members.. ahh, I'm so bad.

"The Standard window is where the Guild’s standard is displayed. Standards are granted as a guild reward and are two handed items that are usable by Standard Bearer’s on the battlefield to grant bonuses to the party (more on Standards below under Guild Standards). From this tab, Guild’s can view their Standard, Edit their Heraldry, set the Standard post, and modify Tactics for the Standard. The Heraldry Editor is accessed from this window,

The Edit Heraldry display allows guilds to choose a unique Heraldry configuration that is displayed on their Guild Standard. Heraldry reservation costs a fee and is granted as a guild reward, though the display of the Heraldry on the Standard is unlocked gradually through the guild rank progression. Heraldry customization options include a shape, base color, pattern, pattern color, emblem, and emblem color (there are 1-10 color variations per emblem)." Source

Ok this one I will cut you a little slack, I can see why you would think I'm copying them.. Though being an art graduate I personally quite like the idea of people able to customise the banners, if I had known this before I probably would have included something similar.

However, I do NOT play Warhammer and I never have.. what I do play is Lotro.. One of my main characters is a level 65 Captain.. Banners.. Captains... Banners... hmmm I think there may be something there.

Truth is, banners in Lotro is nothing new. Captain's aside, Vol 2 has plenty of chapter instances that involve banners, and being able to click on them to change the type of buff it gives you. I don't think any other group reward to be used in a group could be quite as obvious.

I have no idea what buffs the standards in Warhammer give, but given that there's only so many possibilities that will buff a group during play I'd imagine there to be some similarities.

The Reward window I also have no idea about as there's no image. I suppose this is where they chose the standard they want?

I did notice however that WoW also has a similar system http://www.wowwiki.com/Guild_advancement so perhaps Warhammer actually stole the idea from them?

One thing in the UI I suggested I couldn't see in the one from your post is the quest tracker.. Given that the majority of any MMO progression is based around questing of some sort this seems like a natural choice.

Something else I foolishly missed.. an Alliance tab. Says on that website that you can link up kins into a shared alliance interface. Again, something that would be really neat here and has been asked for in the past. Undoubtedly I would have put it in had I ever played Warhammer and known that such a thing could exist.

Kin Bank, does Warhammer have one of these cause I can't see it in those images..

Finally, the Admin section, or Ranks as I called it.
Both of these are the same.. being able to edit kin ranks to change permissions.. This is not unique to Warhammer though. It's also something that has been asked for by players here, myself included.. I would love to have more ranks in the kinship system and be able to change permissions for what each rank can do, I don't need to play another MMO to know that!

I'd just like to conclude in reinforcing the statement that I have never played Warhammer, I never have had the slightest interest to. I would say the majority of the systems I would like to see implemented have come from posts made on these forums by other players, by people I play the game with on my server, and by ideas I would like to see to improve my kinships functionality from a leader perspective.
If that bothers you so much then perhaps ignore this thread and feel free to troll somewhere else.

Well, even on the warhammer wiki there is nothing else to be seen, so I don't know why Deyjarl is so adamant about accusing the OP of "IP theft".

http://warhammeronline.wikia.com/wiki/Guild

As if there was such an original idea among it? It's got good basic "upgrades" for LotRO's kinship interface - obviously neither the design nor outlay was copied and there are only so many ways you can arrange tabs. But I am sure if you look long enough there will be some game out there that looks somewhat similar enough to try and taint the effort that the OP has gone through and the time spend to present this.

But please Deyjarl, do present "what's more to it than listed just on this website" when you happen to have more time than to find the first link that just did not quite have enough to back up what you are saying. At least not to me. The OP has even gone into great detail and your answer was ... rather short and not convincing.

Don't presume to tell us what's possible and what's not please.

Other than that it's almost bordering to harassment the way you are accusing the OP - of course that just my point of view as a bystander.

On the happy side - at least it's not a Wow "clone" - I guess?

Perhaps we could focus on the topic of the thread - a proposed revamp.