+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 40 of 47
  1. #1
    Senior Member Online status: kerryak is offline Reputation: kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Posts
    2,856

    3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Well, it's been a while since we had one of these threads!

    I think that this is a good sign, and while LIs/radiance have a distrinct impact on my playtime, I feel my hunter is in a much better place than it has been historically, and for that I thank Turbine and the Dev Team.

    I have noticed a few things that I feel, as a long-time hunter and avid-forum poster, could round out the class, or address some inconsistencies.

    So, w/o further ado:





    --
    1: Lack of an Induction-Free Interrupt w/in the constraint of the ToF traits/line bonus

    For a CC 'job' (which is what a 5:5 ToF hunter is), an instant interrupt would really round out the profession. In 5:5 ToF w/ Explosive, distracting shot LOSES it's interrupt use as it becomes a perma-mez (PS: thanks for that). This only leaves Bards Arrow and Cry of the Predator, which do not work 100% of the time on all targets.

    Suggestion: Due to the Dev-Confirmed issues w/ disabling auto-attacks for Improved Penatrating Shot for the 4 ToF line bonus (which adds a root), I suggest removing the root functionality and replace it w/ a short stun. This would allow ToF hunters to keep their autoattacks on (this was the point of the combat overhaul, right?), gain an instant stun to interrupt heals/induction moves - but only every 30sec, but at a cost of 25% of their DPS. Due to DR in the Moors, this is now possible w/o being overpowering in PvMP.




    --
    2: Lack of QS enhancement for Fleet Stance.

    Yes, fleet stance stinks, but S:IF has it's uses. However, both stances lack an improvement to Quick Shot, and those improvements enhance their stances with great synergy. S:S's slow makes it ideal for solo/moors, S:E's detaunt (if it works / the tooltip) enhances a reduced threat stance, and S:P's crit stacks nicely w/ pip generation. S:F and S:IF lack such synergy.

    Suggestion: have QS in S:F and S:IF add a slight accuracy debuff to the target w/ a short duration.





    --
    3:Enhancements to Set Snare

    Set Snare doesn't stack w/ other Hunters snares, is not affected by combat traps / strong traps traits, and the damage doesn't scale well relative to level.

    Suggestion: Let Combat Traps apply to snares, Let Strong Traps modify the duration or strength of the bleed, modify snare DoT so that multiple snares can be applied to the same target. Based on these potential enhancements, modify set snare damage.






    --
    Thanks for your time, comments welcome.
    Last edited by kerryak; Mar 16 2010 at 12:25 PM.
    Hat Beerbane, Former .xls Wizard and Hunter Blogger

  2. #2
    Senior Member Online status: NameAlreadyTaken is offline Reputation: NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    6,870

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Yeah, I think the class is in a better place too. It could use a few tweaks to round out a few rough edges though, and those are nice. They address little inconsistencies without being big changes.

    My personal thoughts would be...

    1) That's still not a proper interrupt, although I agree one would be nice. Unfortunately I don't have a good suggestion for where to put an interrupt since Barbed Arrow is no longer lolworthy.

    2) I'd like to see "QS becomes an immediate skill; QS gains a 3 second cool down". There's a lot more synergy with the whole Fleet Stance concept if you can do more than auto attack while moving. You would still have to stop to dump Focus or use ISB/BA/HS/Bard's so I don't think it would be a problem. I know Turbine can do it too as my RK class traits change one of my induction skills to an on the move, immediate skill (which just rocks).

    I'd take about anything though as you are quite on the money when pointing out that S:F is the only stance that doesn't modify QS in any way.

    3) Agreed. Set Snare has always felt like the red headed stepchild of traps. It was a nice idea at the time in SoA but it stands alone, and it's been left behind since level 50.
    7 Level 65s: Champ, Hunter, Guardian, Captain, RK, LM, Burglar
    All of them are sick of grinding Scrolls of Empowerment
    Awaiting change...

  3. #3
    Senior Member Online status: kerryak is offline Reputation: kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Posts
    2,856

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by NameAlreadyTaken View Post
    1) That's still not a proper interrupt, although I agree one would be nice. Unfortunately I don't have a good suggestion for where to put an interrupt since Barbed Arrow is no longer lolworthy.

    2) I'd like to see "QS becomes an immediate skill; QS gains a 3 second cool down". There's a lot more synergy with the whole Fleet Stance concept if you can do more than auto attack while moving. You would still have to stop to dump Focus or use ISB/BA/HS/Bard's so I don't think it would be a problem. I know Turbine can do it too as my RK class traits change one of my induction skills to an on the move, immediate skill (which just rocks).

    I'd take about anything though as you are quite on the money when pointing out that S:F is the only stance that doesn't modify QS in any way.
    TBH: I agree w/ you about my 1st point. But (along w/ corruption removal) I believe Turbine thinks it's too uber, and this rounds out alot of ToF's issues (especially turning AA's off to make the most of IPS, due to IPS not being able to turn off AA's w/o PS turning off AA's as well - DevConfirmed), and if you need an interupt, it's 'traitable' via the line-bonii. I think this is an acceptable compromise, that addresses multiple game-play issues.

    re: QS turning instant but w/ a delayed CD, that's interesting and a good suggestion - more in-line w/ the whole mobility concept.

    I was thinking of the accuracy debuff so that IFS doesn't 'suckazz' vs ranged MOBs, which will just stand there and plink at you, so why run around. an accuracy debuff could make some shots whiff. plus, I thought it'd be funny if they were blinded by my sweet dance moves.
    Hat Beerbane, Former .xls Wizard and Hunter Blogger

  4. #4
    Senior Member Online status: kerryak is offline Reputation: kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Posts
    2,856

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Also...





    --
    4: Bear Hats

    Pariah doesn't like them.

    No really, he doesn't like them.
    Hat Beerbane, Former .xls Wizard and Hunter Blogger

  5. #5
    Grand Member Online status: Forgotten_Legend is offline Reputation: Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    1,244

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    maybe at 66, snare trap could be replaced by something more like a lure trap with a few more hitpoints that we could use as "Bait." it could have a every-2 second- AoE- 10- point- damage- pulse (or a threat pulse/ taunt) or something that could hold aggro for a short time, so we could tank and spank like a captain with his/her archer herald. except of course we couldn't heal it. (maybe a minnie could? nah just kidding) but at least it could last longer than the hand wrought lure traps.

    ToF bonuses would apply to it naturally, so it could actually offer some utility in combat if an extra offtank was temperarily needed. (would still only last 30 seconds or hitpoints zeroed out, whichever came first.)

    lame examples of use... 1) you are ToF hunter in a 6-man, minnie takes a beating, drop a bait trap. pound on it. 2) you are a bowmaster doing "death from below." you toss up a bait trap on the last pull, RoT, the bait trap pulls aggro on every mob that RoT misses (regardless that YOU hit the mobs first, because of the threat pulses) allowing you a little more leeway in the fight. (if you're traited deep enough into ToF, you could drop another bait trap in combat 30 seconds later to draw aggro of whatever mobs are still standing)
    Forgotten_Legend the Baconnaire
    Malinon - 75 Champion | JAZRAIEL - 85 HUNTER | Taeran - 75 RuneKeeper

  6. #6
    Grand Member Online status: SaintBass is offline Reputation: SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    In the van... with candy.
    Posts
    4,017

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    I was going to create a very similar thread since I tend to do so every 6 months or so (more often as needed), but I guess I will just contribute to this one rather than stroke my own ego.

    <brings nothing to the table>
    There are two novels that can change a bookish fourteen-year old's life: The Lord of the Rings and Atlas Shrugged. One is a childish fantasy that often engenders a lifelong obsession with its unbelievable heroes, leading to an emotionally stunted, socially crippled adulthood, unable to deal with the real world. The other, of course, involves orcs.

  7. #7
    Grand Member Online status: Forgotten_Legend is offline Reputation: Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    1,244

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by SaintBass View Post
    <brings nothing to the table>
    you forgot the Vermont cheese again, didn't you? Bree Cheese for you tonight mister...
    Forgotten_Legend the Baconnaire
    Malinon - 75 Champion | JAZRAIEL - 85 HUNTER | Taeran - 75 RuneKeeper

  8. #8
    Senior Member Online status: Duredhel is offline Reputation: Duredhel the Wary Duredhel the Wary Duredhel the Wary Duredhel the Wary Duredhel the Wary
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Posts
    809

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by kerryak View Post
    Yes, fleet stance stinks, but S:IF has it's uses.

    Not to derail this thread, as I think it has real merit to revisit on occasion, but what exactly does S:IF do? Really, I have no idea as I've never tried it. From the tooltip I've assumed it means you don't have to be facing your target, but I am likely wrong...
    Ardent Defender against the Order of Fanatical Anti-Neophyte Braggadocios Ordaining Illogicality
    http://my.lotro.com/duredhel

  9. #9
    Senior Member Online status: kerryak is offline Reputation: kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Posts
    2,856

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    +5 movement before focus loss, -60% reduced miss chance while moving (have to still face target, but can strafe L or R to good effect), but most importantly -10% attack duration. (don't confuse this w/ induction speed.)

    this, in combination w/ needful haste and certain runes on your LI, can get you to -44/45% attack duration. (NH is -25% attack duration, on top of the changes to induction for ISB and Barbed Arrow.)

    It's not often practical in PvE, I use it more in PvMP. but used in combination w/ other things can get you to pop off quite a few shots during a short window when you stack all these attack duration effects.
    Hat Beerbane, Former .xls Wizard and Hunter Blogger

  10. #10
    Grand Member Online status: Forgotten_Legend is offline Reputation: Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    1,244

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    when the tooltip says "Aim" it really means "focus." improved S:F removes the "aim" requirement from standard S:F (which costs you 1 focus per second to upkeep, and is not permitted in combat, so if you never build focus, it lasts 9 seconds in combat, assuming you started with full focus) also, the iS:F can be used out of combat, as well, so it can be maintained "permanently"
    Forgotten_Legend the Baconnaire
    Malinon - 75 Champion | JAZRAIEL - 85 HUNTER | Taeran - 75 RuneKeeper

  11. #11
    Grand Member Online status: jmez is offline Reputation: jmez the Bounders-friend jmez the Bounders-friend jmez the Bounders-friend jmez the Bounders-friend jmez the Bounders-friend jmez the Bounders-friend jmez the Bounders-friend jmez the Bounders-friend jmez the Bounders-friend
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Posts
    2,284

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Just let us be able to use all our skills on the move (cept for maybe HS) ala and rk...and just factor in a miss chance when using a skill while moving. Dont make it so over the top that no shots ever land while moving but maybe 75% accuracy while on the move...wit a legacy to increase it. Turn **** stance (err fleet stance) into that and i'd actually equip it on my hotbar.

    I dunno about the rest of you, but i've grown very annoyed after 2+ years (or however long it's been since this game came out) of have to stop, induct, shot, repeat.

    Even our immediate fire skills, such as pen. shot n merc shot, require us to be standing still. It'd make the class alot smoother n all the nerfs we've had to endure more tolerable imo




    btw, yes we do need an interupt skill and a corruption removal skill thats useful for more then just half the fight...sooooo stupid.


    OT

    Can we PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE get 1 pull down menu for our ports???!? I mean really, do I need to take up a whole hotbar + just to have my ports at the rdy, or go through my skills list to find em. Thats such a minor thing but it'd be so nice to have.

    Plus it'd give me more room to put stuff up I actually use more then every so often, all my bars r full atm

    Jmez Warbringer The Warlord

  12. #12
    Senior Member Online status: NameAlreadyTaken is offline Reputation: NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    6,870

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    We will never see a pull down menu for ports. I agree, and I've been one of the many Hunters asking for it since SoA: Book 9. Unfortunately that ship sailed when Turbine made all skills usable from the Character panel. You don't need a quick slot to use them any more, so I don't see anyone spending time to actually do the drop down menu.

    Yes, I'm a little bitter. I'd have taken that as our L62 'skill upgrade' and been THRILLED too.
    7 Level 65s: Champ, Hunter, Guardian, Captain, RK, LM, Burglar
    All of them are sick of grinding Scrolls of Empowerment
    Awaiting change...

  13. #13
    Counter of Stairs Online status: Ayrolen is offline Reputation: Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    6,844

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by SaintBass View Post
    I was going to create a very similar thread since I tend to do so every 6 months or so (more often as needed), but I guess I will just contribute to this one rather than stroke my own ego.

    <brings nothing to the table>
    Your post sucks.

    Moving on...

    I'd really like some sort of buff to the Snare and your ideas are good ones. I don't have a lot to say regarding the first 2 as I've never traited all the way down ToF (and can't really imagine doing so) and I never even BOUGHT Fleet Stance. lol.
    Ayrolen-Anikosi-Anfribur-Ametrine-Amari-Ayaneth-Asparagus-Anayalos-Alyradal-Aloe-Asiago-Altanoin
    7 Haven Way, Tund Loriel, Falathlorn Homesteads
    Elendilmir Arda Shrugged -Crickhollow The Colonists


  14. #14
    Grand Member Online status: Forgotten_Legend is offline Reputation: Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    1,244

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by Ayrolen View Post
    Your post sucks.

    Moving on...

    I'd really like some sort of buff to the Snare and your ideas are good ones. I don't have a lot to say regarding the first 2 as I've never traited all the way down ToF (and can't really imagine doing so) and I never even BOUGHT Fleet Stance. lol.
    i bought fleet stance... in BETA.. on a character copy... just so i could test it out... you know, make SURE it sucked, instead of just theorizing that it sucked. i even bought the legendary! and i used it... and my conclusion is... i shouldn't have wasted my time in BETA testing it.

    on a positive note: my skill trainer on live is still on my ignore list for having even mentioned fleet stance once.

    on another positive note: all we need is a little moor cowbell!
    Forgotten_Legend the Baconnaire
    Malinon - 75 Champion | JAZRAIEL - 85 HUNTER | Taeran - 75 RuneKeeper

  15. #15
    Senior Member Online status: Silverstein is offline Reputation: Silverstein the Wary Silverstein the Wary
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    360

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Good ideas, I'd love for Turbine to change some aspects and round out the rough edges also.

    Something I would like to add to this conversation would be a new skill that would guarantee and crit on the next skill use, much like the Burglars Aim skill.

    Something like this:

    Fly True: 5 Minute Cooldown, 10 second buff.

    Description: For the next 10 seconds you have a 100% crit chance.

    or

    Description: Your next skill will have a 100% crit chance.


    Something I would also like to see would be a legendary trait that allows hunters to move at 30% speed in camoflauge, to increase the skills usefulness in PVE and in PVP.

    A Harlot's arrow tore my heart.

  16. #16
    Senior Member Online status: NameAlreadyTaken is offline Reputation: NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    6,870

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    I'm going to go out on a limb and say that Turbine will never add a skill that lets you be 100% sure of a Burn Hot/Heartseeker crit from stealth. Having seen people ask for it for years (literally) to no avail I'm pretty confident we won't get to move while Camo'd either.
    7 Level 65s: Champ, Hunter, Guardian, Captain, RK, LM, Burglar
    All of them are sick of grinding Scrolls of Empowerment
    Awaiting change...

  17. #17
    Grand Member Online status: SaintBass is offline Reputation: SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable SaintBass the Indomitable
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    In the van... with candy.
    Posts
    4,017

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by Ayrolen View Post
    Your post sucks.

    Moving on...

    I'd really like some sort of buff to the Snare and your ideas are good ones. I don't have a lot to say regarding the first 2 as I've never traited all the way down ToF (and can't really imagine doing so) and I never even BOUGHT Fleet Stance. lol.
    You think that's bad... this is much worse.


    The issues I was going to bring up are:

    1) The numeric inferiority of Merciful Shot in terms of resources spent and damage done
    Specifically the lack of pay-off unless it crits. I think that the "Quality of Mercy" trait
    would benefit from being modeled after "Unrelenting"

    2) Fleet stance is weak. The focus cost makes it unusable without the legendary trait and
    the legendary trait is far from legendary.

    3) I agree with the previous notions that Set Snare is pretty neglected, but I would like to
    throw in the idea of making it an AoE hotspot and have it affected by "Combat Traps."
    A general traps review and streamline would not be not be un-welcome

    4) Bright Campfire does not scale and has no practical use past level 40. Having it scale
    or provide an in-combat bonus as part of an "improved" skill would help tremendously.

    5) Heartseeker suffers from similar problems as merciful shot, It is inferior in every way
    and has scaled very poorly since its implementation. It is easily outstripped by non DPS
    class skills like Lightning Storm. At the very least, a cooldown and induction time
    reduction is in order.


    Overall, it is not so much that the class is "non-functioning" its just that there are things that are not clearly thought out and would benefit from a final tweaking and balancing pass.
    There are two novels that can change a bookish fourteen-year old's life: The Lord of the Rings and Atlas Shrugged. One is a childish fantasy that often engenders a lifelong obsession with its unbelievable heroes, leading to an emotionally stunted, socially crippled adulthood, unable to deal with the real world. The other, of course, involves orcs.

  18. #18
    Grand Member Online status: Forgotten_Legend is offline Reputation: Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated Forgotten_Legend the Undefeated
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Austin, TX
    Posts
    1,244

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    there you go Bass, making sense again.

    lets put it in perspective (though i don't think we actually NEED to): remorseless strikes (champion class obviously) has a 4.2 second cooldown, can be spammed incessantly alternated with wild strikes (when traited correctly) and crits bigger than merciful shot OR heartseeker

    champions asked for a nuke and they get a superior nuke immediately. hunters ask for a nuke (isn't nuking our primary role?) and our nukes gets nerfed. (traited merciful shot crit gets lowered from 3x to 2.5x) imo HS is only worth using when 5/5 cool burn traited burn hot is active. but then, all the other skills offer more DPS under the same conditions. so its a wash. and not the college fund raiser car wash. so its back to the hut to fry up some more bacon.
    Forgotten_Legend the Baconnaire
    Malinon - 75 Champion | JAZRAIEL - 85 HUNTER | Taeran - 75 RuneKeeper

  19. #19
    Senior Member Online status: Erasmus354 is offline Reputation: Erasmus354 the Wary Erasmus354 the Wary Erasmus354 the Wary
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Posts
    1,600

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    1) Improved Bright Campfire - Gives OOC regen equal to the middle food at your current level. Basically fix the scaling because currently it takes over a minute to just regain the power you used casting the damn thing. Utterly useless.

    2) Advanced Pathfinding - All ports consolidated into a single skill that brings up a drop down of available port locations. The individual skills are still available for anyone who wants to use them.

    3) Merciless Shot - Champions got Remorseless Strike which is pretty insane for ST DPS. Therefore I don't believe it is unreasonable to ask for the crit multiplier on MS to go back to the way it was. This will help us keep up with Champions in ST DPS. Either that or remove the morale requirement so that we have a useful corruption removal. The skill is no longer powerful enough to justify the HP requirement, in fact it kind of sucks now as it is barely better then PS.

    4) True Chain Mez - 30s mez on 30s cd doesn't work for chain mezzing, the mob still wakes up. Make the maxed out a 30s mez on a 25s cd.

    - I don't think we should have an interrupt, that is not our role and isn't really a CC role. Burgs/RK's have the ranged interrupt and Cap/Champ/Grd/Wrd have the melee.

    - I like and agree with QS in IF stance becoming an immediate skill to be used on the run. It fits well with the theme of IF stance and with stances modifying QS.

    Ninja

  20. #20
    Senior Member Online status: Erasmus354 is offline Reputation: Erasmus354 the Wary Erasmus354 the Wary Erasmus354 the Wary
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Posts
    1,600

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by Forgotten_Legend View Post
    imo HS is only worth using when 5/5 cool burn traited burn hot is active. but then, all the other skills offer more DPS under the same conditions. so its a wash. and not the college fund raiser car wash. so its back to the hut to fry up some more bacon.
    Even then it isn't worth using. You will get more DPS by not using HS. Other skills are a more efficient use of your time, and power. HS is a joke and is only good to be used as a fear in the Ettenmoors. That is how bad Turbine has messed up this classes skills. Our 2 "biggest" skills are trivialized and nearly pointless.

    Ninja

  21. #21
    Senior Member Online status: kerryak is offline Reputation: kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Posts
    2,856

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    TBH, I don't think the problem w/ HS is the induction or the power cost. The problem is how the damage is calculated. It doesn't scale as well as the others skills, and it shows. If they changed how the damage is calculated, and normed it so that it's current performance was good for SoA (ie, lvl 50) and we saw more punch at the level cap, it'd basically bring it back to it's intent. As we level up, other skills are just better uses of time/power.

    Just hover over the tooltip.
    Hat Beerbane, Former .xls Wizard and Hunter Blogger

  22. #22
    Poster of Note Online status: SoccerMike is offline Reputation: SoccerMike the Wary SoccerMike the Wary
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Posts
    613

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    1) Improved campfire would be a definite improvemnet if it gave an in combat bonus for regen.

    2) Leave Merciful Shot the way it is but give us another remove buff skill for just that, do not care about the damage.

    3) Would love to see a a skill we click on and all our travel ports are there instead of on 1 whole skill bar. Actually would also like to have an option to remember more than one campfire set while we are at it. It is not like we forget where they are at. If Turbine wants me to be a taxi so be it.

    4) In Fleet stance QS would be nice to add while moving and rain of arrows/thorns. This if it hit you could root stop and fire other skills.

    5) Snare trap make it a AOE trap so maybe start with 3 targets that get snared and have a legacy like the one we have now that would increase the number of targets to be snared. Give it a longer cooldown but would be a nice skill.

    6) AOE poison removal

  23. #23
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Behind a tree, arrow nocked...
    Posts
    3,162

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Until Turbine stop treating the mere existence of a hunter as an exploit, I won't hold my breath for more than trivial changes. Imagine champion horns being consumables like crafted hunter traps, or shield spikes being single use. Imagine nearly every mob constantly running out of melee range, and being able to interrupt a long induction melee strike just by moving back a few steps before it completes.

    I'd like it in a distracting shot didn't get interrupted by existing bleed, and only on new damage like fears. I'd like it if mobs didn't automatically path around trees and rocks and any obstacle available to interrupt a shot. I'd like it of instead of a snare which is marginally useful, we could slot that skill with a resuable crafted trap, be it a tripwire, triple trap, lure trap, etc. Something appropriate to our level.

    But mostly I just wish Turbine would stop being embarrassed by our existence, and understand that hunters are their children too, instead of watching them proudly go off, "This is my son, the Champion. Oh him? The hunter? He's... Did you meet my son, the Champion?"
    Lle merna aut farien?

    Playing music in LotRO is as easy as ABC!

  24. #24
    Counter of Stairs Online status: Ayrolen is offline Reputation: Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    6,844

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by Northwoods View Post
    Imagine champion horns being consumables like crafted hunter traps, or shield spikes being single use.
    Champs have one skill horn (that requires 4 fervour to use - imagine needing focus to put down a trap!) and a crafted horn on a 15 (I think) minute cooldown. That's 10 minutes longer than our crafted traps. If the crafted horn were consumable, they'd have to lower the cooldown significantly, but in turn they'd probably nerf the number of targets it affects.
    Ayrolen-Anikosi-Anfribur-Ametrine-Amari-Ayaneth-Asparagus-Anayalos-Alyradal-Aloe-Asiago-Altanoin
    7 Haven Way, Tund Loriel, Falathlorn Homesteads
    Elendilmir Arda Shrugged -Crickhollow The Colonists


  25. #25
    Counter of Stairs Online status: gildhur is offline Reputation: gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    10,396

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by Northwoods View Post
    Until Turbine stop treating the mere existence of a hunter as an exploit, I won't hold my breath for more than trivial changes. Imagine champion horns being consumables like crafted hunter traps, or shield spikes being single use.
    Champs have a horn skill and a horn item. Hunters have a trap skill and trap items. Additionally, mobs don't walk all over Champ horns. We blow them then put them back on our belt. There's no narrative reason for them to be consumable. Shield spikes ARE consumable.

    Imagine nearly every mob constantly running out of melee range, and being able to interrupt a long induction melee strike just by moving back a few steps before it completes.
    You don't play a melee class much, do you? Mobs DO constantly run out of melee range. At least you don't have to chase them.

    I'd like it in a distracting shot didn't get interrupted by existing bleed, and only on new damage like fears.
    You mean like every other daze in the game? Yeah, Hunters are SO isolated there.

    I'd like it if mobs didn't automatically path around trees and rocks and any obstacle available to interrupt a shot.
    Hunters are not the only ranged class, BTW. Or do you think Minstrels, LMs, Wardens, RKs don't ever have mobs run around things? Also, a lot of people would actually PREFER that mobs be more intelligent and use their surroundings to their advantage. But I can see how Hunters would want them to be dumb and run straight into your arrows so you could keep up.

    I'd like it of instead of a snare which is marginally useful, we could slot that skill with a resuable crafted trap, be it a tripwire, triple trap, lure trap, etc. Something appropriate to our level.
    Marginally useful? You should practice kiting more.

    But mostly I just wish Turbine would stop being embarrassed by our existence, and understand that hunters are their children too, instead of watching them proudly go off, "This is my son, the Champion. Oh him? The hunter? He's... Did you meet my son, the Champion?"
    And I just wish you would stop pretending that Turbine arbitrarily prefers certain classes that they've created over others. It's really pathetic.
    Last edited by gildhur; Mar 18 2010 at 10:04 AM.
    Elendilmir: Arda Shrugged - Crickhollow: The Colonists

  26. #26
    Counter of Stairs Online status: Dom12 is offline Reputation: Dom12 the Bounders-friend Dom12 the Bounders-friend Dom12 the Bounders-friend Dom12 the Bounders-friend Dom12 the Bounders-friend Dom12 the Bounders-friend Dom12 the Bounders-friend Dom12 the Bounders-friend Dom12 the Bounders-friend Dom12 the Bounders-friend
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    3,228

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by Northwoods View Post
    I'd like it if mobs didn't automatically path around trees and rocks and any obstacle available to interrupt a shot.
    Hmm, I actually LIKE that mobs move behind obstacles on their way to us. It feels a lot more realistic. I mean seriously, if you're standing there w/ nothing but a sword & someone starts shooting arrows at you, are you gonna run straight at them instead of dodging behind trees and rocks as you try to get close enough to stick your sword thru them?

  27. #27
    Senior Member Online status: rawlingsst7 is offline Reputation: rawlingsst7 the Undefeated rawlingsst7 the Undefeated rawlingsst7 the Undefeated rawlingsst7 the Undefeated rawlingsst7 the Undefeated rawlingsst7 the Undefeated rawlingsst7 the Undefeated rawlingsst7 the Undefeated rawlingsst7 the Undefeated rawlingsst7 the Undefeated rawlingsst7 the Undefeated
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Location
    Long Island, NY
    Posts
    1,054

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by kerryak View Post
    TBH, I don't think the problem w/ HS is the induction or the power cost. The problem is how the damage is calculated. It doesn't scale as well as the others skills, and it shows. If they changed how the damage is calculated, and normed it so that it's current performance was good for SoA (ie, lvl 50) and we saw more punch at the level cap, it'd basically bring it back to it's intent. As we level up, other skills are just better uses of time/power.

    Just hover over the tooltip.
    Perfect example of SoM combat changes wrecking a skill even further. Individual skill damage: way down.

    "But you can use more skills & autoattacks in the same time!" they say. "So your DPS doesn't suffer!"

    Not during a 5 second induction, we can't.

    Nemesis - Brandywine
    Jenith 65 Hunter || Gavigan 65 Guardian || Kazamir 65 Captain
    Gjorn 65 Champion || Anavel 65 Burglar || Thissis 65 Warden || Mezimus 65 Loremaster

  28. #28
    Senior Member Online status: NameAlreadyTaken is offline Reputation: NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated NameAlreadyTaken the Undefeated
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    6,870

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by gildhur View Post
    Hunters are not the only ranged class, BTW. Or do you think Minstrels, LMs, Wardens, RKs don't ever have mobs run around things? Also, a lot of people would actually PREFER that mobs be more intelligent and use their surroundings to their advantage. But I can see how Hunters would want them to be dumb and run straight into your arrows so you could keep up.
    Can you try not to be a feminine hygiene product and insult everyone that plays a particular class when you're busy insulting one particular poster? Thanks.

    Edited because my initial word choice was filtered.
    Last edited by NameAlreadyTaken; Mar 18 2010 at 10:49 AM.
    7 Level 65s: Champ, Hunter, Guardian, Captain, RK, LM, Burglar
    All of them are sick of grinding Scrolls of Empowerment
    Awaiting change...

  29. #29
    Counter of Stairs Online status: gildhur is offline Reputation: gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    10,396

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by NameAlreadyTaken View Post
    Can you try not to be a feminine hygiene product and insult everyone that plays a particular class when you're busy insulting one particular poster? Thanks.
    I can try, but it's very challenging when it comes to Hunters. You're usually so unanimous in your frothing outrage.
    Elendilmir: Arda Shrugged - Crickhollow: The Colonists

  30. #30
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Behind a tree, arrow nocked...
    Posts
    3,162

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by gildhur View Post
    I can try, but it's very challenging when it comes to Hunters. You're usually so unanimous in your frothing outrage.
    Aside from trolling, why do you even bother hanging out in the hunter's forum?
    Lle merna aut farien?

    Playing music in LotRO is as easy as ABC!

  31. #31
    Counter of Stairs Online status: Ayrolen is offline Reputation: Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire Ayrolen Protector of the Shire
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    6,844

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by Northwoods View Post
    Aside from trolling, why do you even bother hanging out in the hunter's forum?
    One could ask you the same thing, considering how much work Phivex put into improving our class during the last beta. It's one thing to come here and list constructively some of the things you'd like to have changed/added to our class and it's another thing to come here with a huge chip on your shoulder, acting like we're broken and Turbine has some sort of hidden agenda. Get over yourself.
    Ayrolen-Anikosi-Anfribur-Ametrine-Amari-Ayaneth-Asparagus-Anayalos-Alyradal-Aloe-Asiago-Altanoin
    7 Haven Way, Tund Loriel, Falathlorn Homesteads
    Elendilmir Arda Shrugged -Crickhollow The Colonists


  32. #32
    Senior Member Online status: kerryak is offline Reputation: kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Posts
    2,856

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by gildhur View Post
    I can try, but it's very challenging when it comes to Hunters. You're usually so unanimous in your frothing outrage.


    Eh, I dunno. I'd have to want to play to be outraged again.

    Alot of us are either playing permadeath b/c endgame sucks, or doing other things, like basking in the warmth of our mother star, visiting the 'rents, or college friends.

    Maybe it's just me, but SG #106 [ for .15*(1/6) odds of getting a symbol for a (.4*.3*.2*.1) chance at better DPS ] vs <insert just about any RL topic here>.

    Last 12 logins: Hey guys, what are you doing? Oh, solo skirms? SG? Doesn't anyone want to do anything else? No? Yeah, waiting on raid locks blows. Like raid gear, LOL!!!! Hey, let me talk about what I'm eating. Yeah, it's tasty. OK, loveyallbyebye.

    Hell, I watched that ****** Syfy movie 'Meltdown' w/ Casper Van Diem where the earth moves closer to the sun and OMG WE'RE ALL GOING TO BAKE TO DEATH vs login to LOTRO. That was hilariously stupid. But it was more entertaining than solo skirm Thangulhad #331.

    We'll know I'm totally done when I prefer squeezing the lemons for my hefeweissen into my eye for kicks over logging in.
    Hat Beerbane, Former .xls Wizard and Hunter Blogger

  33. #33
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Behind a tree, arrow nocked...
    Posts
    3,162

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by gildhur View Post
    I don't. I was linked to this particular thread by someone and thought your mewling post was worthy of retribution. Is there some kind of minimum forum section post count quota I don't know about?
    So then you're only purpose in posting was to attack a fellow player?
    Lle merna aut farien?

    Playing music in LotRO is as easy as ABC!

  34. #34
    Counter of Stairs Online status: gildhur is offline Reputation: gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte gildhur the Neophyte
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Houston, TX
    Posts
    10,396

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by Northwoods View Post
    So then you're only purpose in posting was to attack a fellow player?
    If that's all you got out of my half a dozen specific answers to your comparisons between Hunters and other classes, then there's no point in even answering you anymore.
    Elendilmir: Arda Shrugged - Crickhollow: The Colonists

  35. #35
    Senior Member Online status: CWood is offline Reputation: CWood Protector of the Shire CWood Protector of the Shire CWood Protector of the Shire CWood Protector of the Shire CWood Protector of the Shire CWood Protector of the Shire CWood Protector of the Shire CWood Protector of the Shire CWood Protector of the Shire CWood Protector of the Shire CWood Protector of the Shire
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Kannagi <mine>
    Posts
    3,810

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by Dom12 View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by Northwoods View Post
    I'd like it if mobs didn't automatically path around trees and rocks and any obstacle available to interrupt a shot.
    Hmm, I actually LIKE that mobs move behind obstacles on their way to us. It feels a lot more realistic. I mean seriously, if you're standing there w/ nothing but a sword & someone starts shooting arrows at you, are you gonna run straight at them instead of dodging behind trees and rocks as you try to get close enough to stick your sword thru them?
    Agreed. Additionally, it'd be neat (though probably too difficult) if we could "hold" a completed induction until we got a clear shot. Maybe add that feature in as a bonus to S:Fleet to make it suck less.
    ::: The Waywatchers of Cardolan : The Palantiri :::
    Balgr Snowmantle: Curmudgeon :.Saladoc Willowleaf: Stick-in-the-mud
    Ciruth of Gondor: Itinerant Scholar : Halvr, Khasi Flamebrow, and Kholi: At your service!

    Austreven.of Cobalt (Bismarck)

  36. #36
    Grand Member Online status: Kannos1600 is offline Reputation: Kannos1600 the Bounders-friend Kannos1600 the Bounders-friend Kannos1600 the Bounders-friend Kannos1600 the Bounders-friend Kannos1600 the Bounders-friend Kannos1600 the Bounders-friend Kannos1600 the Bounders-friend Kannos1600 the Bounders-friend
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    PA
    Posts
    4,737

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    I agree with what Kerryak posted on a few changes to the Hunter Class. Although If I could only have 3 I would like these: They may go with some of what Kerryak said already and others but hey. I can only read so much when I just wake up and being harassed by other people in my apartment. (its only one person but still )
    • Set Snare to work with Combat Traps and scale to the Hunter Level to become more useful with higher lvl players.
      I know it was mentioned before but I would like to see other Hunters realize the use of Set Snare vs Set Trap all the time. Since Snare doesnt deal alot of damage alot of hunters ignore it just as they did Barbed Arrow until as of recent times. It be nice to know others use the skill just as I do in combat against certain foes.
    • QS to gain a buff from Fleet Stance.
      As all other stances garner a bonus to QS I think Fleet Stance should as well. While kiting around the room maybe allow QS to be used on the move. Although somehow I see this being a balance issue since somewhere someone is going to say its to powerful or some **** like that but still. Something for QS in this stance would make Fleet Stance be part of the Stance Family rather than that Cousin we all hate. It can at least be a Cousin we all hate thats close to the family
    • Penetrating Shot to be our Corruption Removal Skill vs Merciful Shot but instead of 3 Corruptions it removes only 1.

    Other Changes Id like to see on my account alone:
    • For one day my Heartseeker renamed HADUKEN

    That is all. Just one day to an hour of having my HS renamed HADUKEN just to see it on screen and giggle fit my way to the Print Screen button
    Last edited by Kannos1600; Mar 18 2010 at 02:46 PM.

  37. #37
    Member Online status: OldFool is offline Reputation: OldFool the Wary OldFool the Wary
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    49

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by kerryak View Post
    Eh, I dunno. I'd have to want to play to be outraged again.

    Alot of us are either playing permadeath b/c endgame sucks, or doing other things, like basking in the warmth of our mother star, visiting the 'rents, or college friends.

    Maybe it's just me, but SG #106 [ for .15*(1/6) odds of getting a symbol for a (.4*.3*.2*.1) chance at better DPS ] vs <insert just about any RL topic here>.

    Last 12 logins: Hey guys, what are you doing? Oh, solo skirms? SG? Doesn't anyone want to do anything else? No? Yeah, waiting on raid locks blows. Like raid gear, LOL!!!! Hey, let me talk about what I'm eating. Yeah, it's tasty. OK, loveyallbyebye.

    Hell, I watched that ****** Syfy movie 'Meltdown' w/ Casper Van Diem where the earth moves closer to the sun and OMG WE'RE ALL GOING TO BAKE TO DEATH vs login to LOTRO. That was hilariously stupid. But it was more entertaining than solo skirm Thangulhad #331.

    We'll know I'm totally done when I prefer squeezing the lemons for my hefeweissen into my eye for kicks over logging in.
    Hacker-Pschorr?

  38. #38
    Member Online status: OldFool is offline Reputation: OldFool the Wary OldFool the Wary
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Posts
    49

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by gildhur View Post
    If that's all you got out of my half a dozen specific answers to your comparisons between Hunters and other classes, then there's no point in even answering you anymore.
    That works for me. In future, please refrain from answering any of us.

  39. #39
    Senior Member Online status: kerryak is offline Reputation: kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable kerryak the Indomitable
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    Posts
    2,856

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by OldFool View Post
    Hacker-Pschorr?
    depends - Naturtrub isn't stocked commonly @ distributors, and not restocked at alot of the classer bars. PA is a weird state re: distribution, can only buy by case, or 6 or 12 from a bar.

    But damn it's good.
    Hat Beerbane, Former .xls Wizard and Hunter Blogger

  40. #40
    Senior Member Online status: Aidus is offline Reputation: Aidus the Wary Aidus the Wary Aidus the Wary Aidus the Wary
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Posts
    1,060

    Re: 3 reasonable changes to the hunter, as seen by a veteran hunter

    Quote Originally Posted by OldFool View Post
    That works for me. In future, please refrain from answering any of us.

    Please speak for yourself. While I don't always agree with Gildur I appreciate his input and find he handles serious valid discussions in the manner in which the issues are presented. If you don't like his response perhaps you should look to how you posted your information.

    Thanks that is all! If you wanna flame me go for it, I have been around to long to care.

    Have a nice day!


    "Live and Let Die"

+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts