-
Apr 23 2008 08:41 PM #281
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
there is no pvp here, just keeps and alot of npc's that freeps/creeps rely on to force wipes of the other side and either consider it a roll or think they are farming

"There may come a time for valor without renown, for those without swords may surely still die upon them."
-
Apr 23 2008 08:41 PM #282
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
Manhands 50, rank 6 minstrel Leader TABA (nimrodel!!!)
Boraborn 50 hunter, rank 7 (pre book 12)
Starfarmer rank 5, 5 star, Warg
-
Apr 24 2008 10:01 AM #283
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
I love freep raids with koll leading them. They are amazing, and the most fun i've had in this game in ages.
Irphor
-
Apr 24 2008 10:08 AM #284
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
Last night was a good laugh right before Thunderherald hit rank 7 (and congratulations to him on that!) and that sort of stuff I miss in the Ettenmoors. I just think it's more of the people that are there in the raids than the overall tactics.
When you have good people leading, and 23 other people listening, and everybody having a good time then the Ettenmoors can be great.
Now if only I can get that warrior title - creeps beware!⎨ There can be no prestige without mystery. ⎬

-
Apr 24 2008 10:16 AM #285
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
im too lazy to actually read anything in this thread, but i do have oen thing to say:
peace is so overrated
Ambein, lvl 66 Human LM - SM Scholar | Lengram, lvl 47 Elf RK - SM Jeweller
Officer We're All Going to DIE!
-
Apr 24 2008 07:33 PM #286
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
-
Apr 24 2008 07:49 PM #287
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
-
Apr 24 2008 08:00 PM #288
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
it bothers me that burgs HIPS during a 1v1 combat when it doesn't go their way.. just bad form.

"There may come a time for valor without renown, for those without swords may surely still die upon them."
-
Apr 24 2008 08:07 PM #289
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
Boy I've been gone a long time. You can call me Taorin
Olagaton: Yes I'm sure. I wouldn't have typed it if I wasn't sure.
-
Apr 24 2008 08:21 PM #290
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
I couldn't disagree more. Whether a burg is incredibly overpowered in pvp is one thing, but I use and expect others to use every skill they have to win and not die for the benefit of the group. I expect hunters to DF and if they don't they are probably stupid (not brave). I expect a warg to disappear and try and escape or make it back for the bubble and if they don't they aren't playing to their fullest or supporting the group. There are always exceptions to this but I certainly don't consider it bad form to use all the skills available.
The Bees have chosen.
Order Through Chaos
-
Apr 24 2008 09:10 PM #291
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...

"There may come a time for valor without renown, for those without swords may surely still die upon them."
-
Apr 24 2008 09:45 PM #292
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
Boy I've been gone a long time. You can call me Taorin
Olagaton: Yes I'm sure. I wouldn't have typed it if I wasn't sure.
-
Apr 24 2008 11:33 PM #293
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
Escaping is definitely part of winning. People do it in other games all the time. Standing there and taking a beating you can't win seems foolish to me. Somewhere in this game we invented some odd rules about pvp that we expect other people to adhere to.
When the Delving came out some burg tried to gank me from Grams to DG on my BA. He wasn't very good and I would make it to the NPC's before he could kill me and he couldn't quite stand up to a few NPCs plus having me root/snare/DOT him. I think it would have been stupid of me to feed him renown and try and solo him and I felt good about getting away. I also think it was smart of him to leave until he could get an opportune moment. He called some freep friends to help but I made it to DG by then.
So my point is that you shouldn't expect other people to play by rules that a subset of players invent. The only real rule I have (or had) was that if you're grouping to support the group to the best of your ability. Even though I hate cross vent communication and flipping they aren't rules I cant expect others to adhere to.The Bees have chosen.
Order Through Chaos
-
Apr 25 2008 02:07 AM #294
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
Amurard, d'entre les morts
-
Apr 25 2008 04:33 AM #295
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
My Milkshake Brings All The Brothers To The Yard!
Tsion - R10 Captain, Candyman of Nimrodel
Leader/Founder of The Dancing Tsions™
Throwing Axe KB Count: 5Collector of Juice™
-
Apr 25 2008 06:01 AM #296
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
Yep and bingo. If you have to run away then you are defeated to a point. There is nothing wrong with that in my opinion. Why give up your gold/renown/infamy/items for a total nuke defeat? Whats the purpose in that? This game has no real pvp penalty. Hell it barely has a pve death penalty so maybe you don't care if you die, but most competative pvp games have some sort of penalty (you drop money, items, and/or lose status and xp).
Pulling back to make another attack seems like a much smarter strategy than just sitting there and dying.
And yes that burg wasn't very good, but he was persistent. I'm sure with much more practice he's now ganking the hell out of newbie creeps.The Bees have chosen.
Order Through Chaos
-
Apr 25 2008 08:32 AM #297
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
If you accept a 1V1, fight for a while and then run away once you realize that you are screwed you are nothing more than a coward. there is no penalty, unless you are a R10 with 5stars and you get killed by a greenie with a zero rating your rating will not drop more than 10. It is disrespectful and cheap to deny your victorous opponent with well earned renown/infamy.
That is if you ACCEPT the 1v1, if you know that there is no way that you'll win and or dont feel like fighting then whatever, df hips or sprint away!
-
Apr 25 2008 08:58 AM #298
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
You should die because if you fight in the 1v1, you accept the challenge of it and you think you can win. If you run away without trying to fight in the first place then you either don't think you can win or you're just a starhugger, but I guess go ahead and try to get away. But accepting a 1v1, fighting it down till you have 500 health and then hitting HiPS is just pathetic.
Amurard, d'entre les morts
-
Apr 25 2008 12:45 PM #299
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
Like I said you guys can make up your own rules and create your own honor system all you want but no one has to accept it. In fact most people probably don't read these forums and have no idea what kind of convoluted system you've created to make yourselves feel like better pvp players.
There is no penalty at all in this game at all. There is a minor repair bill (big deal), but no real incentive to survive. Stars mean nothing. If you were say to lose 10% of your wealth or drop your weapon or armour you were wearing or perhaps delevel then you would consider how cowardly living to the next fight really is. Who cares about starhugging. Why do people "hug stars"? Because it's a way to try and add value and merit to a meritless casual intramural style of pvp.The Bees have chosen.
Order Through Chaos
-
Apr 25 2008 12:48 PM #300
-
Apr 25 2008 02:32 PM #301
-
Apr 25 2008 03:53 PM #302
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
PREP...
was it really necessary to call in another defiler after going at it for that long..
thought we had a good thing going there
</3Turelion - r9 lrm <Infamous>
Roukan - r7 Stlkr <Scrubs>
-
Apr 25 2008 08:52 PM #303
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
Well thank you for proving yourself wrong. Amurard is right, its pathetic to run away. If you are afraid of dying stay out of the moors. If someone im soloing pulls that **** you better believe ill spend at least the rest of the night hunting them down, if they die with "Honor" I might even jump around them next time as a friendly gusture :-)

-
Apr 25 2008 09:58 PM #304
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
No one has proven anything. All that's been proven is people on our server invent a bunch of arbitrary rules and expect other people to abide by them. You can't expect that. That was really my original point. Obviously we disagree and aren't going to convince each other. I do admit there isn't any reason not to die in this game because it has not penalty. That's pretty lame pvp though. It also means that victory pretty much is meaningless as well.
The Bees have chosen.
Order Through Chaos
-
Apr 25 2008 10:20 PM #305
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
This conversation is funny. It all boils down to perspective. After all the push and pull action we all see in the 'moors, I'm surprised many of you don't understand that retreat can be as much a part of success as it is defeat. Retreat does not always equal defeat or loss. Take, for example, Lee in the Civil War. His army would push, kill many soldiers from the Union army, retreat to recompose, regather, reposition themselves, and push again; rinse/repeat. He was very successful in doing so until Grant came along and decided to continuously push his army while Lee was retreating.
Thus, in context, use of escape skills can be strategic moves to recompose, regather and reposition ones self to go at it again. If the rule is to the death, then a living HIPS/Disappear/DF'er has not died, and thus has not lost - though he hasn't won yet either.I guarantee your level 65 r0 greenie BA will contribute more to your Creep raid than my level 2 Minstrel will contribute to my Freep raid. After all, both took about 5 seconds to create.

-
Apr 25 2008 11:12 PM #306
-
Apr 25 2008 11:42 PM #307
-
Apr 25 2008 11:51 PM #308
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
lol i knew if we talked long enough slither would come out of his hole. Well, what you said was completely irrelivant and typical justifacation for being a pansy. I believe that you sould use your skills like dissapear to beable to repounce and stun your opponent. You and you on your other account are talking about running away with your tails between your legs with no intentsion of coming back to finish the fight.
I agree that the penalty for dying is slim to none, but I think if they incorporated a harsher penalty nobody would fight 1v1, they would be "Using all thier skills" aka hiding in the middle of the raidshooting ppl with thier bows.
-
Apr 26 2008 01:24 AM #309
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
That's your own rule. That's cool. I personally think healers should heal in 1v1's, if they have them available. Not using them is a poor move on their part - whether their intentions are honorable or not. I have beaten every class in the game 1v1, so it's not like it's impossible to beat someone that does use all their skills. Therefore, there is no real reason why someone should be forced/convinced to hold back. Assuming the 1v1 isn't some type of preliminary, if you choose not to use all the tools given to you, that's your decision, but don't expect your opponent to do the same. Assuming the 1v1 isn't some type of preliminary, if you choose not to use all you have, and you lose - you lose, plain and simple.
Hmm, I wonder. Gurthag asked to keep the thread peaceful, and his tribemate can't even honor his request.Why the hell did you bring Gurthag in btw? Optima is a tribemate #1 and #2 if the thread catches fire (like 100% of all the other threads) then that's sad and annoying but it's not like he alone can stop it.
Feel free to. Just because someone says that running away is cowardly doesn't mean it is - that's a matter of opinion, and in this case an all-or-nothing opinion. However, when someone runs away, and then is able use that to an advantage which allows him a victory, that is evidence (not opinion) that running away can be used in a non-cowardly, but instead strategic manner. One example to disprove an all-or-nothing opinion is all it takes to make that opinion lose weight. It was once said that to win a debate, you need not prove that you're right, but simply prove that your opponent is wrong. It works quite well, actually.Sure I could tell you to shut up and quit trying to make it seem like you are heroic when in fact you are running away, and that accomplishes what? Sure I get a moment of exictement from telling you to shove it but it's not going to stop you from posting.
LOL, who uses Real Life stuff to justify actions in a video game? Just....Everyone.P.S. Who the hell uses an actual War to justify a video game???I guarantee your level 65 r0 greenie BA will contribute more to your Creep raid than my level 2 Minstrel will contribute to my Freep raid. After all, both took about 5 seconds to create.

-
Apr 26 2008 01:43 AM #310
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
RANDOM INTERJECTION
If it is a set up 1v1 fight, and you run away, you have lost.
If it is a random encounter, then both players could have won.
The person who almost beat the other because he did more damage
and the person that got away, because the other person did not kill him.
This is merely my interpertation on the subject.Lore-Masterin' since 1899
-
Apr 26 2008 01:58 AM #311
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
you lost the bet, gosh thats to bad
. I couldnt ignore it forever! Im off to ignoring you again :-)

-
Apr 26 2008 02:54 AM #312
-
Apr 26 2008 09:12 AM #313
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
Drop it here people...the subject has been covered and entered the flaming stages.
Drop it...
Or, if you cannot do so, start another thread.
Let us all help amu get his last point.
Keidynce -- Bael -- Celebriath
Evil and Stuff Like That
Gurthag -- Halwabu -- Druth -- Draghkar -- Snagnakh -- Sigh
The Black Blade
-
Apr 26 2008 09:33 AM #314
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
I guarantee your level 65 r0 greenie BA will contribute more to your Creep raid than my level 2 Minstrel will contribute to my Freep raid. After all, both took about 5 seconds to create.

-
Apr 26 2008 12:12 PM #315
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
Part of me wants to kill Turbine >< I had a error when I DL'd book 13 so I have to Reinstall Lotro. I'm at 11000/14000... so I'll be on my defiler at lunch...for the first time...

I wish I had hoarded DP before this but I'll do fine I guess. Also I feel sorry for all the weavers out there, I loved playing Salzor but now I'm really thinking about reseting him for the name haha he is only R5 but i poured a lot of time into him, only to have his only tool become the same as hindering shot. Maybe this was a conspiracy to make BA's more playable >.>
-
Apr 26 2008 12:14 PM #316
-
Apr 27 2008 08:25 AM #317
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
-
Apr 27 2008 09:46 AM #318
-
Apr 27 2008 12:29 PM #319
-
Apr 27 2008 02:09 PM #320
Re: Nimrodel's First Peaceful PvMP Thread...
As a roving warg, it's not easy for me to tell the difference between "playful creep sparring with freep buddy" and "innocent creep fighting to survive against evil freep." If someone's having trouble in an engagement with the enemy, my tendency is to jump in, attack, try to keep them alive, and ask the questions later. Because it's less frustrating for a sparring pair to have to restart than it is for a questing creep to end up splattered all over the nearest rez circle.
Maybe start wearing afk tags saying "Sparring, do not disturb" if you don't want well-intentioned help?
-
- Community Guidelines
- New Posts
- Dev Tracker
- Forum List
- Discussion Forums
- Classes
-
Worlds
- Arkenstone
- Brandywine
- Crickhollow
- Dwarrowdelf
- Eldar
- Elendilmir
- Evernight
- Firefoot
- Gilrain
- Gladden
- Imladris
- Landroval [EN-RE]
- Laurelin [EN-RP]
- Meneldor
- Nimrodel
- Riddermark
- Silverlode
- Snowbourn
- Vilya
- Windfola
- Withywindle
- Anduin [DE]
- Belegaer [DE-RP]
- Gwaihir [DE]
- Maiar [DE]
- Morthond [DE]
- Vanyar [DE]
- Estel [FR-RP]
- Sirannon [FR]
- Bullroarer (Public Test Server)
- Community
- Gameplay
- PvMP






Reply With Quote
I don't know about you, but I'm glad I at least I got 8-9 months of fun outta it before it got so stale that I find myself logging in, joining a raid and being like 'what am I doing here?' and clicking the little exit game button.


